Name: Screenwise
Author: Screenwise

Where to Read

Amazon

Barnes & Noble

Libby

Our reviews and ratings are 100% unbiased, but as an Amazon Associate, Screenwise earns an affiliate fee if you buy a book or game by clicking one of our links. We don't get any credit if you just Google it instead :)

Screenwise Verdict

The Witch Haven delivers on atmosphere—1911 New York, secret witch schools, dark academia vibes—and Sasha Peyton Smith creates a genuinely moody historical fantasy world. The found family elements are strong, and Frances's moral dilemmas about power and revenge have real weight.

But let's be honest: this follows every YA fantasy beat you've seen before. Orphaned girl discovers magic, mysterious bad boy teaches forbidden knowledge, evil man wants to control her power, mentor figures warn her away. The romance with dream-boy Finn has some uncomfortable undertones (he's literally appearing in her head to teach her dangerous magic), even if it's meant to be swoon-worthy.

The opening violence is jarring, and there are real deaths and gore throughout—this isn't Hogwarts-lite. Common Sense Media's 13+ rating is spot-on. If your teen loved dark academia TikTok and wants witchy historical fiction with actual stakes, this delivers. If they want something original or less tropey, keep looking.

Solid 4.2 on Amazon, 3.7 on Goodreads—which tells you it's competently done but not revolutionary. A good pick for confident teen readers who know what they're getting into with darker YA fantasy.

Age Fit

Best for ages 13-17 who are comfortable with darker YA fantasy. The violence, death, and morally ambiguous romance make this too intense for middle grade readers, while older teens might find the familiar tropes predictable.

WISE Breakdown

Wholesome

68

The book models sisterhood and found family well, with Frances finding community at Haxahaven. However, it opens with a violent death (man with scissors in his neck), includes themes of murder investigation and revenge for a brother's death, and features romantic tension that complicates the protagonist's moral choices. The emotional tone is darker than typical YA fare, with grief, danger, and moral ambiguity throughout. Common Sense Media notes violence including deaths, attempted murder, and some gore.

Imaginative

77

Strong historical fantasy premise—1911 New York witches disguised as a sanitarium is genuinely creative. The magic system, secret societies, and the tension between safe institutional magic versus dangerous forbidden knowledge creates interesting world-building. The dark academia vibes and boarding school setting invite readers into a richly atmospheric world. However, it follows fairly standard YA fantasy beats (chosen one attracts powerful villain, romantic subplot, mentor warnings ignored) without reinventing the wheel.

Safe

62

Common Sense Media flags violence including deaths, attempted murder, some gore, and kissing/romance. The opening scene involves an unexplained violent death that could be jarring. Themes include murder, revenge, manipulation by a male antagonist seeking control, and a protagonist drawn to dangerous power despite warnings. The romance involves a mysterious boy who appears in dreams teaching forbidden magic, which has some grooming-adjacent vibes even if unintentional. Not graphic or explicit, but darker content than many YA fantasies with real stakes and deaths.

Enriching

71

Explores themes of female power, autonomy, and the price of justice versus safety. The historical setting (1911 NYC, women's limited options as seamstresses) provides context for understanding women's history. Frances must grapple with moral complexity—choosing between personal revenge and community safety, between seductive power and ethical restraint. The found family and sisterhood elements offer positive relationship modeling. However, the 'girl tempted by bad boy with forbidden knowledge' trope is well-worn territory, and the entertainment value outweighs deeper philosophical exploration.

Parent Info

✓

Why It Might Be Great

Genuinely atmospheric historical fantasy set in 1911 New York with a witches-disguised-as-sanitarium premise that works
Strong found family and sisterhood themes as Frances discovers her magical community at Haxahaven
Explores real moral complexity: revenge versus safety, personal power versus community responsibility
Dark academia boarding school vibes for readers who want something moodier than typical YA fantasy
Historical context about women's limited options (seamstress work, lack of autonomy) provides feminist lens without being heavy-handed

⚠

What to Watch For

Opens with a violent death (scissors in neck) that Frances can't explain—immediate intensity that sets a darker tone
The mysterious dream boy teaching forbidden magic has some uncomfortable grooming-adjacent vibes, even if unintentional
Multiple deaths, murder investigation, and revenge plot throughout—this isn't cozy magic school
Romance complicates Frances's judgment in ways that might frustrate readers who want a stronger protagonist
Common Sense Media rates it 13+ for violence, deaths, and some gore

Conversation Starters

"Frances has to choose between getting justice for her brother and protecting her new witch community. What would you do in her place?"
"Why do you think the headmistress warns against powerful magic? Is she being protective or controlling?"
"Finn teaches Frances forbidden magic in her dreams. Does that feel romantic or kind of manipulative to you?"
"What would it have been like to be a young woman in 1911 with so few options beyond being a seamstress?"
"If you discovered you had magic, would you want to learn everything possible or stick to 'safe' magic?"

Ask Anything

Get a personalized guide on any topic

The Witch Haven Sasha Peyton Smith