Our reviews and ratings are 100% unbiased. Screenwise is a Bookshop.org affiliate and an Amazon Associate, so if you buy a book through one of our links, we may earn a commission. Bookshop.org purchases also support independent bookstores.
Screenwise Verdict
This is the kind of book English teachers assign that kids actually end up liking. Gary Schmidt pulls off something tricky: making Shakespeare feel relevant and a 1960s coming-of-age story feel immediate. Holling is funny, flawed, and real—his voice carries you through even when the pacing slows.
The Wednesday Wars isn't flashy or action-packed, but it's genuinely enriching without being preachy. Kids learn about literature, history, and character through a story that feels personal rather than educational. The relationship between Holling and Mrs. Baker is particularly well-done—watching mutual respect develop over the school year is satisfying.
It requires reading stamina and an appreciation for character over plot. Reluctant readers might bounce off it, but kids who already like books will find this rewarding. The Vietnam War backdrop and family tension add weight without being overwhelming. Solid choice for thoughtful middle schoolers ready for literary fiction that doesn't talk down to them.
Age Fit
Best for independent readers ages 10-14 who can handle character-driven stories with historical context. The Shakespeare references and 1960s setting require some maturity, but the humor and seventh-grade perspective keep it accessible. Strong readers on the younger end will enjoy it; older middle schoolers will appreciate the nuance.
WISE Breakdown
Wholesome
88
Models genuine character growth, respect across differences, and standing up for family. Holling learns to admire his teacher despite initial hostility, shows loyalty to his sister, and confronts his domineering father. The relationship between student and teacher is particularly well-drawn, showing mutual respect developing over time. Set against the Vietnam War backdrop, it handles serious themes with age-appropriate sensitivity while maintaining humor and heart.
Imaginative
82
Weaves Shakespeare into a 1960s middle school story in an original way that makes the Bard accessible and relevant to modern kids. Each month is a new chapter exploring different plays, and the parallel between Holling's life and Shakespeare's themes is clever without being heavy-handed. The Vietnam War setting and suburban Long Island details create a vivid historical world. However, it's more character-driven literary fiction than fantastical or wildly creative—it invites reflection more than active imagination.
Safe
85
No graphic content, sexual material, or language concerns. The Vietnam War context includes age-appropriate references to the conflict and its impact on families, but nothing gratuitously violent or traumatic. Holling's domineering father and family tension are realistic but not abusive or triggering. Common Sense Media and parent reviews consistently note it as appropriate for ages 10+. The emotional content—family stress, war anxiety, coming-of-age struggles—is handled with care and humor.
Enriching
90
Newbery Honor winner that introduces Shakespeare in an engaging, accessible way while exploring Vietnam-era America, family dynamics, and personal integrity. Holling's growth from self-centered to empathetic, his evolving understanding of Mrs. Baker, and his willingness to stand up to his father offer strong ethical modeling. The Shakespeare integration is genuinely educational without being preachy. Beautifully written with humor and depth—kids learn about literature, history, and character simultaneously.
Parent Info
✓
Why It Might Be Great
Makes Shakespeare actually interesting and relevant—kids might even want to read Macbeth after this
Funny and real about middle school life while tackling serious themes like war, family pressure, and finding your voice
Beautifully written without being boring—Gary Schmidt knows how to make literary fiction feel alive
Strong character arc showing genuine growth from self-absorption to empathy and courage
Historical setting (1968) offers a window into Vietnam-era America that feels personal, not textbook-y
⚠
What to Watch For
Requires reading stamina—this is literary fiction, not a quick page-turner
Vietnam War references and family tension around the war; handled sensitively but may prompt conversations
Holling's father is emotionally cold and controlling; realistic family dysfunction that resolves positively
Best for kids who already like reading; reluctant readers may struggle with the pacing and Shakespeare references
Conversation Starters
"Why do you think Mrs. Baker assigned Shakespeare to Holling? What was she trying to teach him?"
"How does Holling change throughout the year? What moments made him grow up?"
"What do you think about how the Vietnam War affected families in the book? How would you feel if someone you knew was drafted?"
"Holling's dad cares a lot about his business image. When is it okay to stand up to your parents?"
"Which Shakespeare play would you want to read after this book?"
