Name: Screenwise
Author: Screenwise

Where to Watch

Loading streaming options...

Screenwise Verdict

Here's the truth: The Secret Garden (1993) is a beautiful, emotionally intelligent film with genuinely enriching themes about healing, nature, and human connection. The problem? It's a 30-year-old period piece that moves at Victorian speed.

If you have a bookish, patient kid who loves Anne of Green Gables or can sit through a slow-burn story, this delivers. The garden restoration is visually gorgeous, the emotional arcs are satisfying, and the messages about nurturing life (both plant and human) are legitimately profound.

But let's be real: most modern kids will find this borderline unwatchable. The pacing is glacial, the accents are thick, and the whole vibe screams 'assigned school reading.' The opening with dead parents and themes of childhood neglect also require emotional maturity—this isn't light viewing.

It's a shame because the content is genuinely WISE-aligned. But the 'watchability penalty' is real here. Save this for the right kid at the right moment, maybe after they've read the book or if they're already into classic adaptations. Otherwise, you're fighting an uphill battle against TikTok-trained attention spans.

Age Fit

Best for ages 8-13 who can handle slow pacing and heavy themes. Younger kids may struggle with the deliberate storytelling and emotional weight; older teens will likely find it too dated and slow unless they're into classic literature adaptations.

WISE Breakdown

Wholesome

82

Classic story of healing, friendship, and emotional growth. Models kindness through the children's restoration of the garden and each other's spirits. Themes of overcoming grief and neglect are handled gently. The pacing is deliberate and contemplative, which is wholesome but may feel slow to modern viewers.

Imaginative

78

The locked garden as a metaphor for hidden potential is beautiful. The film invites curiosity about nature, restoration, and discovery. The manor's secrets and the children's detective work spark imagination. However, it's more contemplative than actively creative—kids watch rather than participate in world-building.

Safe

88

Very safe content overall. Parents die in an earthquake (off-screen), and themes of grief and neglect are present but handled sensitively. No violence, gore, or inappropriate content. The emotional weight of loss and loneliness might be heavy for very young or sensitive children, but nothing is shocking or traumatic in presentation.

Enriching

75

Strong themes about healing from trauma, the therapeutic power of nature, and how nurturing living things can restore the soul. Explores class dynamics (servant/master relationships) and disability with surprising nuance for a family film. The emotional intelligence is high, though the Victorian setting may feel distant to modern kids.

Parent Info

✓

Why It Might Be Great

Genuinely beautiful themes about how caring for living things (plants, people) can heal grief and trauma
One of the better adaptations of the classic novel, with solid performances and atmospheric cinematography
Models emotional intelligence and perseverance without being preachy
The garden restoration is genuinely satisfying to watch unfold
Handles disability, class, and loss with more nuance than most modern kids' films

⚠

What to Watch For

Parents die in the opening (earthquake, off-screen)—sets up the whole 'orphan sent to gloomy manor' thing
Themes of childhood neglect and emotional abandonment run throughout
This is SLOW. Like, 1993 period drama slow. If your kid needs constant action, they'll tap out in 15 minutes
The Yorkshire accents are thick and the Victorian setting feels very distant from modern life
One character is believed to be disabled and kept hidden—it's handled sensitively but is still heavy

Conversation Starters

"Why do you think taking care of the garden helped Mary feel better?"
"Have you ever felt lonely or left out like Mary did at the beginning? What helped you feel better?"
"Why do you think Colin's dad kept him hidden away? Was that fair to Colin?"
"What would you plant in a secret garden if you had one?"
"How did Mary change from the beginning to the end of the movie?"

Ask Anything

Get a personalized guide on any topic