2025
WISE Score
Amazon
High-stakes magic meets 'I hate you but I'm obsessed with you' energy in this dark fantasy sequel.
4.4
4.4View →Our reviews and ratings are 100% unbiased, but as an Amazon Associate, Screenwise earns an affiliate fee if you buy a book or game by clicking one of our links. We don't get any credit if you just Google it instead :)
If your teen is already deep into Sarah J. Maas or Caraval, this is a no-brainer. It’s well-written, hits all the right emotional beats, and doesn't treat its audience like they're too young to handle complex moral choices.
Just be aware that 'sultry' is the industry's polite way of saying the romance gets heated. It’s not 'brain rot'—it’s actually a pretty dense, well-plotted fantasy—but it’s definitely more about the sparks flying than a simple bedtime story.
This is firmly for the 14+ crowd. While younger teens might pick it up for the magic, the romantic intensity and darker themes are geared toward older high schoolers and adults who love a good 'romantasy.'
It's a romantasy, so expect heavy doses of angst, betrayal, and intense emotional conflict. While it models some growth regarding responsibility, the 'enemies-to-lovers' vibe thrives on tension rather than traditional kindness.
The magic system involving Lightfire and Shade magic is well-realized, and the world of Valterre feels distinct enough to keep readers hooked beyond the romance.
As a 'dark fantasy,' there is magic-based violence and assassin-related peril. The 'sultry' descriptor from Kirkus suggests significant romantic tension and potentially some 'spice' that might be too much for middle-schoolers.
Doyle digs into the identity crisis of Ransom Hale and the burden of leadership for Sera. It’s a solid look at how power can change a person's path and the ethics of rebellion.
If your teen has been haunting the "Young Adult" section of the bookstore lately, they’ve likely already heard of Catherine Doyle. The Rebel and the Rose is the heavy-hitter sequel that fans have been waiting for, and it leans hard into the "romantasy" trend that’s currently dominating the charts. It’s a specific flavor of storytelling: one part intricate magic system, one part high-stakes political rebellion, and three parts "I want to kiss you but I might have to stab you first."
Doyle doesn't waste time with a slow burn here. Since this is the second book in the City of Fantome series, the tension between Seraphine and Ransom is already at a boiling point. It’s a NYT bestseller for a reason—it delivers exactly what the audience wants: emotional payoff and a world that feels dangerous enough to matter.
You’ll see the word "sultry" pop up in almost every professional review of this book. In the context of 2025 YA fiction, that’s a signal. It means the romance isn't just a side plot; it’s the engine. While the book stays within the bounds of Young Adult, it pushes the envelope on physical tension. If you're trying to figure out if the "spice" level is a dealbreaker for your specific kid, our parent's guide to The Rebel and the Rose breaks down exactly what that "sultry" tag looks like in practice.
Beyond the romance, the "dark fantasy" label is earned. This isn't a sanitized fairy tale. There is betrayal and shade magic, along with the kind of violence you’d expect from a story about an assassin leading the Order of Daggers. It’s gritty, but it’s not gratuitous.
This is the natural next step for readers who graduated from the whimsical, puzzle-box energy of Caraval and want something with more "teeth." It’s also a great fit for fans of Margaret Rogerson’s work, where the magic feels ancient and slightly terrifying.
The magic system—Sera’s lightfire versus the creeping shade magic—provides a solid framework for the plot. It’s not just "magic for magic’s sake." It’s a metaphor for the internal struggle both leads are facing. Sera is trying to control a power that feels like it’s burning her up, while Ransom is trying to lead a group of assassins without losing his soul. If your teen enjoys stories where the heroes are flawed and the villains are complicated, this will hit the spot.
Get a personalized guide on any topic
