Name: Screenwise
Author: Screenwise

Where to Watch

Loading streaming options...

Screenwise Verdict

Here's the thing: the story of the Oxford English Dictionary's creation is objectively cool. A professor and an asylum patient exchanging thousands of word definitions by mail? That's a great premise.

But this movie got absolutely destroyed by critics (Metacritic 27!) while audiences were much kinder (80% RT audience score). That split usually means the execution is rough—pacing issues, uneven performances, or just a failure to make compelling what should be compelling.

The content is heavy: murder, mental illness, Victorian asylum conditions, likely self-harm. This isn't a feel-good historical romp; it's a serious drama about serious subjects. For the right teen (15+) who's into period dramas and can handle dark themes, there's genuine enrichment here about language, history, and redemption.

But let's be real: most modern teens will find this slow, dated, and hard to engage with. The WISE score reflects that this has educational value and interesting themes, but it's a tough watch that won't appeal broadly. If your kid is a history buff or genuinely fascinated by language, give it a shot. Otherwise, there are better ways to spend two hours.

Age Fit

Best for ages 15+ who have a genuine interest in historical drama, language, or Victorian history. Younger teens may find it too slow and heavy; older teens who aren't into period pieces will be bored senseless. This is not a crowd-pleaser.

WISE Breakdown

Wholesome

65

A period drama about intellectual collaboration and unlikely friendship between a professor and an asylum patient. The film models dedication, forgiveness, and human connection across social boundaries. However, the story involves a murder, mental illness, and institutionalization, with some emotionally heavy themes that may be disturbing. The pacing is deliberate and contemplative, which some may find slow.

Imaginative

58

The concept of creating the Oxford English Dictionary is inherently fascinating—cataloging every word in the English language is a monumental creative endeavor. The film explores the power of language and the unlikely partnership between two brilliant minds. However, this is a historical drama that doesn't particularly invite creative expression or exploration from viewers; it's more of a straightforward biographical narrative. The imaginative elements are in the subject matter rather than the storytelling approach.

Safe

45

Common Sense Media rates this at 13+, and there are significant safety concerns. The film depicts a murder (Dr. Minor killed a man, which is why he's in the asylum), mental illness including delusions and self-harm, and institutionalization in a Victorian-era asylum. There are likely disturbing scenes of psychological distress and potentially graphic content related to Minor's condition. The low Metacritic score (27) and mixed critical reception suggest execution issues that may make difficult content even harder to watch. This is not a film where a younger child could stumble in unexpectedly without encountering potentially traumatic material.

Enriching

72

The historical significance of the Oxford English Dictionary and the true story behind its creation is genuinely enriching. It explores themes of redemption, the power of purpose, mental illness with some nuance, and the transformative nature of intellectual work. The film offers insight into Victorian-era attitudes toward mental health and the painstaking work of lexicography. However, the low Metacritic score (27) versus decent audience scores (80% RT audience, 7.2 IMDb) suggests the film may not execute its enriching premise as effectively as it could have. Still, the subject matter itself is educational and thought-provoking.

Parent Info

✓

Why It Might Be Great

The true story of creating the Oxford English Dictionary is genuinely fascinating—10,000+ entries from an asylum patient is wild
Explores themes of redemption, purpose, and unlikely friendship across social boundaries
Educational about Victorian-era attitudes toward mental illness and the painstaking work of lexicography
Strong audience scores (80% RT, 7.2 IMDb) suggest it resonates despite critical panning
Could spark interest in language, history, and the power of intellectual work

⚠

What to Watch For

Depicts murder, mental illness, asylum conditions, and likely self-harm—this is heavy material not suitable for younger teens
Slow-paced period drama that even interested viewers may find tedious (that Metacritic 27 is brutal)
Victorian-era asylum scenes may be disturbing and include outdated, harsh treatment of mental illness
The critical-audience score split (27 vs 80) suggests this is polarizing—you'll either find it moving or plodding

Conversation Starters

"What do you think it would be like to spend years cataloging every single word in the English language?"
"How do you think society's understanding of mental illness has changed since Victorian times?"
"Dr. Minor found purpose and redemption through his work on the dictionary—have you ever had a project that helped you through a difficult time?"
"Why do you think the dictionary editors continued working with Dr. Minor even though he was in an asylum for murder?"

Ask Anything

Get a personalized guide on any topic

The Professor and the Madman