Name: Screenwise
Author: Screenwise

Where to Read

Amazon

Barnes & Noble

Libby

Our reviews and ratings are 100% unbiased, but as an Amazon Associate, Screenwise earns an affiliate fee if you buy a book or game by clicking one of our links. We don't get any credit if you just Google it instead :)

Screenwise Verdict

Here's the thing: this is a beautifully curated anthology with real literary merit, edited by someone who knows children's literature inside and out. If you have a bookish 10-year-old who devours everything and you want to give them a sense of where modern kids' books came from, this delivers.

But let's be real—most modern kids are going to find this a slog. The newest story is from 1992, and most are much older. The pacing is slower, the language is more formal, and the concerns of 18th and 19th century children (governesses, strict moral lessons, Victorian school life) feel like ancient history. Even good older children's lit can be tough for kids raised on fast-paced, dialogue-heavy contemporary fiction.

This works best as a shared-reading project or a coffee table book you dip into occasionally, not something you hand a kid and expect them to devour cover-to-cover. It's enriching in the way a museum visit is enriching—valuable, educational, but not exactly a theme park. If your kid is already a reader who enjoys classics, go for it. If they're on the fence about reading, this will push them over the wrong edge.

Age Fit

Best for 9-12 year olds who already enjoy reading and have the patience for older, slower-paced stories. Younger kids (7-8) could handle it as a read-aloud if parents provide context. Teens are unlikely to pick this up unless they're genuinely into literary history or assigned it for school.

WISE Breakdown

Wholesome

82

A thoughtfully curated anthology spanning 250 years of children's literature, edited by Carnegie Medal winner Jan Mark. The collection emphasizes classic storytelling values—fairy tales, school adventures, ghost stories—with an emotionally healthy tone appropriate for 9-12 year olds. Some stories reflect dated attitudes (stricter gender roles, colonial perspectives) but these can spark meaningful conversations about how childhood and values have evolved. Overall wholesome in intent and execution, though not perfectly aligned with 2025 sensibilities.

Imaginative

78

The anthology spans from Sarah Fielding's 1749 'The Governess' to Nadia Wheatley's 1992 'Convict Box,' offering 44 different authors across multiple genres—fairy tales, ghost stories, school adventures. This variety invites kids to experience different narrative styles and historical periods. However, as a collection of older short stories (nothing past 1992), it leans more toward literary appreciation than the kind of explosive creativity or world-building that modern kids expect. It's imaginative in scope and historical range, but may feel quaint rather than mind-bending.

Safe

92

Books are inherently safe, and this anthology is designed specifically for 9-12 year olds by a respected children's literature editor. No content warnings flagged in search results. The most notable concern is that some stories reflect historical attitudes that may feel uncomfortable (gender roles, colonial perspectives), but these are learning opportunities rather than safety issues. No graphic content, no inappropriate themes for the target age range.

Enriching

85

This is a literary education in a single volume—44 authors across 250 years, arranged chronologically to show the evolution of children's storytelling. Kids get exposure to classics (Alcott, Kipling, Rossetti) alongside lesser-known gems, building literary literacy and historical perspective. The variety of genres and styles builds reading range. For families who value literary heritage and want kids to understand where modern children's lit came from, this is genuinely enriching. However, entertainment value may lag behind enrichment—these are 'important' stories more than page-turners.

Parent Info

✓

Why It Might Be Great

Edited by Carnegie Medal winner Jan Mark, so you're getting expert curation of the 'best' short stories for kids from 1749-1992
44 different authors across multiple genres means real variety—fairy tales, ghost stories, school adventures, historical fiction
Chronological arrangement lets kids (and parents) see how children's literature evolved over centuries, which is genuinely cool for literary-minded families
A single volume that introduces classics like Alcott and Kipling alongside obscure gems—builds literary literacy without hunting down individual books
Safe, wholesome content designed for 9-12 year olds; nothing shocking or inappropriate

⚠

What to Watch For

Nothing published after 1992, and most stories are much older—this will feel dated to kids raised on Percy Jackson and Diary of a Wimpy Kid
Some stories reflect historical attitudes about gender, class, and colonialism that may feel uncomfortable or require context
Better suited for kids who already love reading and have patience for older storytelling styles; reluctant readers will bounce right off this
Works best as a shared-reading or bedtime book where parents can provide historical context and skip stories that don't land

Conversation Starters

"Which story felt the most old-fashioned to you? What made it feel that way?"
"How do you think kids' lives were different when this story was written? What's changed, and what's stayed the same?"
"If you could write a modern version of one of these stories, which would you pick and how would you update it?"
"Some of these stories have ideas about boys and girls that feel weird now—why do you think people thought differently back then?"
"Which author's style did you like best? Do you want to read more of their work?"

Ask Anything

Get a personalized guide on any topic

The Oxford Book of Children's Stories