Is the mermaid stuff... weird?

Yes. It's not a Disney mermaid. It's a surreal, disturbing, and highly anatomical hallucination that plays into the characters' sexual frustration and madness.

What's the deal with the seagull scene?

It is a pivotal moment of violence where a character brutally kills a bird. It's filmed in a very visceral, lingering way that is upsetting for animal lovers.

Do I need to know anything about mythology first?

Not strictly, but it helps. The movie draws heavily on the myths of Prometheus (the man who stole fire/light and was punished) and Proteus (the old man of the sea). Knowing those makes the ending feel less 'random' and more 'inevitable.'

Is it actually a horror movie?

It's more of a 'psychological thriller' or 'folk horror.' There are no monsters jumping out of closets, but the atmosphere is heavy with dread, and there are some truly gross-out moments.

The Lighthouse – WISE Score & Parent Review | Screenwise

The Lighthouse

Name: Screenwise
Author: Screenwise

movie2019

58%

WISE Score

Willem Dafoe and Robert Pattinson lose their minds in a boxy, black-and-white fever dream of booze, mermaids, and seagulls.

7.5

→

The Lighthouse

movie

2019

58%

WISE Score

Willem Dafoe and Robert Pattinson lose their minds in a boxy, black-and-white fever dream of booze, mermaids, and seagulls.

7.5

Jump to

Also rated on

7.5

View →

Where to Watch

Loading streaming options...

Where-to-watch data byJustWatch

Screenwise Verdict

The Lighthouse is a masterpiece, but it’s a masterpiece that wants to make you feel as miserable and insane as its characters. It’s loud, smelly (you can practically smell the kerosene and sweat through the screen), and deeply bizarre.

If you’re looking for a light thriller or a fun fantasy flick, run away. This is high-art psychological horror that demands your full attention and a very strong stomach. It’s one of the best films of the 2010s, but it’s also a movie where Willem Dafoe curses a man with a five-minute monologue about Neptune. Know what you’re getting into.

Age Fit

This is strictly for adults and maybe the most seasoned, film-obsessed older teens. Between the masturbation, the gore, and the sheer psychological weight, it's not 'family movie night' material.

WISE Breakdown

Wholesome

It is intentionally the opposite of wholesome. It’s a grimy, booze-soaked descent into madness featuring flatulence, mutual hatred, and animal cruelty.

Imaginative

Visually and narratively stunning. The 1.19:1 aspect ratio, 19th-century maritime dialect, and mythological surrealism create an atmosphere unlike anything else in modern cinema.

Safe

Hard R-rating for a reason. Includes full-frontal male nudity, graphic violence (including a brutal scene with a seagull), and disturbing sexual imagery involving a mermaid.

Enriching

As a piece of art, it's a masterclass in acting and cinematography. It rewards deep analysis of folklore, isolation, and the human psyche, provided the viewer is mature enough to handle it.

Parent Info

✓

Why It Might Be Great

Acting clinic provided by Dafoe and Pattinson, who both turn in career-defining, unhinged performances.
Atmospheric immersion that makes you feel the salt spray, the dampness, and the claustrophobia of the 1890s New England coast.
Mythological depth that blends Prometheus, Proteus, and maritime superstition into a dense, rewarding puzzle.
Visual audacity using vintage lenses and a nearly square frame to create a haunting, archival look.

⚠

What to Watch For

There is a graphic scene involving a seagull that is genuinely difficult to watch and may be a major trigger for many.
Full-frontal male nudity and a very weird, semi-sexualized encounter with a mermaid carcass/hallucination.
The dialogue is heavily stylized 19th-century dialect; you might actually need subtitles to understand what they're yelling at each other.
The sound design is dominated by a constant, jarring foghorn that is meant to be annoying and succeeds.

Conversation Starters

"Why do you think the light was so important to Thomas, and what did Ephraim actually see in it?"
"How does isolation change the way these two men treat each other versus how they'd act in a city?"
"Is the movie a literal story of two guys going crazy, or is it all a metaphor for something else?"
"What did the seagull represent, and why did killing it change the 'luck' of the island?"

Deep Dive

The Robert Eggers Experience

If you saw The Witch, you know Robert Eggers doesn't do 'halfway.' He builds worlds that feel 100% authentic to their time period, right down to the syntax of the insults. The Lighthouse takes that obsession to an extreme. Filmed on 35mm black-and-white film with custom-made lenses to mimic early 20th-century photography, the movie looks like a relic dug up from a shipwreck.

Why It's Polarizing

The film is essentially a two-man play. Robert Pattinson plays the newcomer, 'Ephraim Winslow,' a man with a secret who just wants to do his job and get paid. Willem Dafoe is 'Thomas Wake,' the veteran lighthouse keeper who treats Winslow like a slave and treats the lighthouse lamp like a goddess. The friction between them starts with chores and farts, and ends with axes and ancient curses.

"Darn ye! Let Neptune strike ye dead, Winslow!"

It’s funny in a pitch-black way, but the humor is buried under layers of grime. For parents, the 'Safety' score here is the primary hurdle. It’s not just the violence—which is blunt and messy—it’s the pervasive sense of dread and the explicit sexual fantasies that make it a 'wait until the kids are at sleepaway camp' watch.

Comparison to Other Horror

Unlike the jump-scare fests of the Conjuring universe, The Lighthouse is interested in the horror of the mind. It shares more DNA with The Shining or Persona than it does with modern slasher films. If your teen is a burgeoning cinephile who talks about 'composition' and 'A24,' they’ll likely love it, but for anyone else, it’s a challenging, albeit brilliant, slog.

What Parents Ask

Ask Anything

Get a personalized guide on any topic