Our reviews and ratings are 100% unbiased. Screenwise is a Bookshop.org affiliate and an Amazon Associate, so if you buy a book through one of our links, we may earn a commission. Bookshop.org purchases also support independent bookstores.
Screenwise Verdict
Natasha Preston knows her lane. This isn't high-brow literature, but it's a high-octane thriller that actually understands 2026 digital culture. It’s the literary equivalent of a summer slasher movie—fun, a little bit trashy in the best way, and a total page-turner for a teen who wants a book they won't want to put down.
It’s not 'brain rot,' but it is pure entertainment. If your kid is into mystery or survival stories, this is a solid pick, provided they're okay with a story where not everyone makes it off the island.
Age Fit
Best for ages 13 or 14 and up. It's a classic YA thriller—plenty of tension and some murder, but nothing a teen who has seen a PG-13 horror movie can't handle.
WISE Breakdown
Wholesome
45
It's a slasher thriller where the main hook is watching characters get picked off. While it's not 'dark' in a nihilistic way, the tone is centered on peril and survival rather than kindness or cooperation.
Imaginative
72
The setting—a Gothic-themed amusement park designed specifically for influencers—is a clever, modern take on the 'locked room' mystery. It builds a vivid, creepy world that feels very 'now.'
Safe
65
As a YA thriller, it involves murder and significant suspense. It's 'safe' for the intended teen audience who knows what they're getting into, but the body count and tension make it inappropriate for younger or sensitive readers.
Enriching
60
It offers a decent critique of influencer culture and the performative nature of social media. It's more 'popcorn' entertainment than a deep moral study, but it sparks thought about digital fame.
Parent Info
✓
Why It Might Be Great
It captures the 'content creator' world without feeling like an out-of-touch adult wrote it.
The fast-paced, 'pulse-pounding' style is perfect for kids who usually find reading a chore.
The Jagged Island setting is genuinely atmospheric and creative, moving beyond a standard 'spooky house' trope.
⚠
What to Watch For
The body count is real; characters die in ways that might be too intense for middle-schoolers.
The characters are influencers, which means some are intentionally shallow or annoying, which can be a turn-off if you want deep protagonists.
Conversation Starters
"If you were offered a VIP trip in exchange for posting about it, would you look for the catch?"
"How much of an influencer's life do you think is actually real versus what they show on camera?"
"Which of the six characters did you think was the most 'authentic,' and did that help them survive?"
