Our reviews and ratings are 100% unbiased. Screenwise is a Bookshop.org affiliate and an Amazon Associate, so if you buy a book through one of our links, we may earn a commission. Bookshop.org purchases also support independent bookstores.
Screenwise Verdict
This is the book equivalent of a warm hug wrapped in whimsy and righteous anger at systems that harm vulnerable people. It's tender, funny, and genuinely moving—the kind of story that makes you believe in kindness while also making you want to burn down unjust bureaucracies.
The magical children are an absolute delight (the Antichrist is six and loves his button collection, I mean come on), and the romance between Linus and Arthur is one of the loveliest in contemporary fantasy. It's not preachy, but it definitely has something to say about acceptance, chosen family, and standing up for people society wants to erase.
The controversy around this book is mostly from people who see any LGBTQ+ content as 'propaganda,' which tells you more about them than the book. For families comfortable with queer characters and themes of social justice, this is a gem. For middle schoolers through adults who want fantasy with heart and a backbone.
Age Fit
Common Sense Media says 12+, and that feels right. The LGBTQ+ romance and themes of institutional discrimination are better suited for middle schoolers and up who can grasp the nuance. Adults love this book too—it's not just for kids.
WISE Breakdown
Wholesome
88
A deeply kind story about found family, acceptance, and choosing love over bureaucracy. Models compassion, standing up for marginalized people, and creating safe spaces for those who are different. The central romance between two middle-aged men is tender and age-appropriate (one long-awaited kiss). Some emotional heaviness around themes of discrimination and children in institutional care, but handled with warmth and hope.
Imaginative
82
Whimsical fantasy world with magical children including a gnome, a wyvern, a blob, and the literal Antichrist (who's six years old and loves his button collection). The premise—a bureaucrat sent to evaluate whether magical orphans will end the world—is quirky and original. Theatrical narration and colorful characters create a vivid, enchanting atmosphere. Not groundbreaking fantasy worldbuilding, but charming and inventive in its character work.
Safe
85
Very safe for its target audience (12+). One romantic kiss between men, no graphic content, no surprise violence or gore. Some mild scariness around the children's powers and themes of institutional discrimination against magical beings. The controversy mentioned in search results is about LGBTQ content being labeled 'propaganda' by some readers, but this reflects bias rather than actual safety concerns. Common Sense Media rates it 12+ with appropriate context.
Enriching
86
Tackles meaningful themes: prejudice, bureaucratic dehumanization, chosen family, and what it means to protect vulnerable people. Linus's journey from rule-following bureaucrat to someone who questions unjust systems offers real ethical growth. The book teaches empathy for outsiders and the courage to challenge harmful institutions. Emotional intelligence around trauma, belonging, and love. Lambda Literary Award winner. Entertaining and heartfelt without being preachy.
Parent Info
✓
Why It Might Be Great
Genuinely heartwarming found-family story that will make you feel things—features a caseworker who learns to choose people over paperwork
Magical children are delightful: a garden gnome, a shapeshifting blob, a wyvern, and a six-year-old Antichrist who collects buttons and records
Tender LGBTQ+ romance between two middle-aged men that's sweet without being sanitized—just a really lovely love story
Tackles real themes (discrimination, institutional harm, protecting vulnerable kids) with both gravity and hope
Lambda Literary Award winner with a 4.6 Amazon rating—beloved by adult readers for good reason
⚠
What to Watch For
The LGBTQ+ romance is central to the plot—if that's not a fit for your family values, this isn't your book (though honestly, it's 2025)
Themes of children being harmed by institutions and discrimination might be heavy for sensitive middle schoolers
Written in a whimsical, almost children's-book style, but the themes and pacing are definitely for older readers—a 10-year-old might find it slow
Conversation Starters
"Linus has to decide between following the rules and doing what's right. When have you had to make a choice like that?"
"The kids in this book are treated badly because they're different. How do you think we should treat people who seem 'different' from us?"
"Arthur would do anything to protect the children, even if it means breaking laws. Do you think there are times when breaking rules is the right thing to do?"