Our reviews and ratings are 100% unbiased. Screenwise is a Bookshop.org affiliate and an Amazon Associate, so if you buy a book through one of our links, we may earn a commission. Bookshop.org purchases also support independent bookstores.
Screenwise Verdict
This is one of those rare books that works on multiple levels—accessible enough for reluctant readers with its verse format and basketball action, but deep enough to win major literary awards. The graphic novel adaptation makes Alexander's already engaging story even more dynamic.
The emotional weight is real. A parent dies, and while it's handled with care and builds throughout the story, younger or more sensitive kids might need support. But that's also what makes it valuable—it gives kids language and framework for grief, family stress, and growing up.
The basketball backdrop is a smart hook, but this is really about brotherhood, identity, and navigating family crisis. It's the kind of book that stays with kids and opens up conversations about hard topics. Strong representation, authentic voice, and genuinely moving without being manipulative. A solid pick for middle schoolers ready for something with substance.
Age Fit
Best for ages 10-14 (5th-8th grade). The verse format and illustrations make it accessible for younger middle schoolers or reluctant readers, while the emotional depth and family health crisis storyline requires maturity to process. High schoolers might enjoy it but will likely age out unless they're nostalgic or reading with younger siblings.
WISE Breakdown
Wholesome
88
Alexander's graphic novel adaptation handles family dynamics, grief, and growing up with emotional authenticity. The story centers on twin brothers navigating basketball, first crushes, parental stress, and a heart-stopping family health crisis. The tone is age-appropriate for middle schoolers—dealing with real emotions (jealousy, fear, loss) without being preachy. Models sibling relationships that feel genuine, with conflict and resolution. The verse format and visual storytelling create balanced pacing that never feels chaotic.
Imaginative
82
The novel-in-verse format translated to graphic novel is inherently creative—short, rhythmic text paired with dynamic illustrations that capture basketball action and emotional beats. The visual style suits the fast-paced, beat-driven narrative. While it's not asking readers to build or create themselves, it models creative storytelling through verse and visual art, showing how poetry can tell a compelling sports story. The format itself invites kids to think about narrative structure differently.
Safe
92
Common Sense Media confirms this is clean content appropriate for 12-year-olds. The story deals with a serious health crisis (a parent's heart condition and eventual death), but it's handled with care and is telegraphed through the narrative—not a shock moment. No violence, gore, inappropriate content, or mature themes beyond the emotional weight of family illness. The Goodreads parent review confirms 'content is as clean as it gets while still retaining conflict and emotion.' The grief and loss are age-appropriate for middle grade readers who can handle emotional depth.
Enriching
86
Won the Newbery Medal and Coretta Scott King Award for good reason. Tackles complex themes: brotherhood, growing up, first love, parental expectations, grief, and identity. Offers genuine insight into family dynamics, particularly African American family life. The basketball backdrop provides accessible entry point while delivering real emotional and ethical growth. Builds empathy through authentic characters facing real challenges. The verse format also enriches literacy by showing poetry as a storytelling vehicle. Strong representation and relatable middle school experiences.
Parent Info
✓
Why It Might Be Great
Award-winning story (Newbery Medal, Coretta Scott King Award) that hooks reluctant readers with verse format and dynamic illustrations
Authentic portrayal of twin brothers, African American family life, and middle school growing pains—first crushes, sibling rivalry, parental pressure
Basketball action makes it accessible for sports-loving kids while delivering genuine emotional depth about family, loss, and identity
The graphic novel format makes the verse structure even more engaging—perfect for visual learners or kids who think they don't like poetry
Tackles grief and family health crisis with care and authenticity, giving kids language for hard emotions
⚠
What to Watch For
The story involves a parent's serious heart condition and eventual death—emotionally heavy but handled appropriately for middle grade readers
Best for kids ready to engage with real grief and loss, not just light reading
Some kids may need support processing the family health storyline
Conversation Starters
"Josh and Jordan have really different ways of dealing with their dad's health problems. How do you think you'd handle something scary like that?"
"The twins start growing apart when Jordan gets a girlfriend. Have you ever felt like a friend was changing or pulling away?"
"Josh breaks the rules and it has serious consequences. Why do you think he did it, and what would you have done differently?"
"The whole book is written like poetry with a beat. Did that make it easier or harder to read? Did you like it?"
