Our reviews and ratings are 100% unbiased. Screenwise is a Bookshop.org affiliate and an Amazon Associate, so if you buy a book through one of our links, we may earn a commission. Bookshop.org purchases also support independent bookstores.
Screenwise Verdict
This is one of those rare kids' books that actually does what it promises: it gives young children a simple, memorable framework for understanding their emotions. The color metaphor is intuitive, the Monster is endearing, and the little girl guide is patient and kind—great modeling.
The pop-up edition is a genuine treat (Kirkus called the illustrations 'downright splendid'), and parents report reading it nightly without losing their minds, which is high praise. Teachers and therapists love it because it works—kids genuinely start using the color language to express themselves.
It's not trying to be profound or literary; it's trying to help a 4-year-old say 'I feel red and black at the same time' instead of throwing a block. And it succeeds. A must-have for the emotional toolkit bookshelf.
Age Fit
Perfect for ages 3-7, especially during the preschool/kindergarten years when emotional regulation is a daily adventure. Older kids might enjoy it as a read-aloud with younger siblings, but it's really aimed at the early childhood crowd learning to name their inner weather.
WISE Breakdown
Wholesome
95
A gentle, emotionally intelligent book that validates all feelings without judgment. The little girl helps the Monster sort emotions with patience and kindness—no shame, no 'bad' feelings, just understanding. The tone is calm and supportive, perfect for helping kids feel safe exploring their inner world.
Imaginative
88
The central metaphor—assigning colors to emotions—is simple but genuinely clever and sticky for young minds. The pop-up edition adds tactile, visual wonder. It invites kids to create their own color-emotion systems and has spawned countless classroom art projects. Not groundbreaking conceptually, but executed with real charm and multimedia flair that Kirkus called 'downright splendid.'
Safe
100
Zero concerns. No scary content, no surprise distress, no inappropriate themes. It's a picture book about naming feelings. The Monster character is adorable and non-threatening. Parents and therapists use this with kids who have big emotions precisely because it feels safe and contained.
Enriching
92
This is a genuine social-emotional learning tool disguised as a charming story. It builds emotional vocabulary, self-awareness, and the foundational skill of identifying what you're feeling—critical for regulation. School Library Journal notes it 'allows for the understanding that one can have many emotions at once,' which is sophisticated for the age group. Widely used by counselors, therapists, and educators. High utility, not just entertainment.
Parent Info
✓
Why It Might Be Great
Gives kids a concrete, visual language for abstract feelings—'I'm feeling yellow today' is way easier than 'I'm experiencing joy'
The pop-up edition is genuinely delightful; kids want to read it over and over just to see the 3D pages
Validates that all emotions are okay and that feeling multiple things at once is normal, not confusing or bad
Author Anna Llenas is an art therapist, so this isn't just cute—it's grounded in actual emotional development practice
Sparks natural follow-up activities: drawing emotion jars, making color charts, talking about what makes you feel each color
⚠
What to Watch For
Some kids might fixate on 'matching' their feelings to the exact colors in the book—remind them everyone's color-emotion map can be different
If your kid is already emotionally articulate, this might feel a bit basic, but it's still a sweet read
The pop-up version is more expensive and can get torn by rough handlers—the flat version works just fine for the concept
Conversation Starters
"What color do you think your feelings are right now? Can you have more than one color at the same time?"
"The Monster felt all mixed up when his emotions were tangled. Have you ever felt like that? What helps you feel less mixed up?"
"If you could pick any color for happy (or sad, or angry), what would you choose? Does it have to be the same as the book?"
"Who helps you sort out your feelings when they're all jumbled, like the little girl helped the Monster?"