Name: Screenwise
Author: Screenwise

Where to Watch

Loading streaming options...

Screenwise Verdict

This is exactly what it promises to be: a feel-good holiday movie about misfits finding acceptance. The 97% audience score isn't lying—families are eating this up because it balances humor with genuine heart.

The story's strength is taking the 'bad kids' seriously rather than just making them one-dimensional troublemakers. Yes, the Herdmans steal, lie, and terrorize, but the film digs into why—poverty, neglect, survival mode—without getting preachy. It's a solid entry point for talking about empathy and economic inequality with elementary-aged kids.

The 2024 timing works in its favor—unlike trying to get kids to sit through the 1983 TV version or read the 1972 book, this adaptation is fresh enough to hold modern attention spans. That said, it's still fundamentally a wholesome Christmas pageant story, so if your kids need Marvel-level action or TikTok-paced editing, they might squirm.

The main watch-out is that younger kids (under 8) might miss the nuance and just see 'bad behavior is funny' without grasping the redemption arc. But for the target 8-12 range, this is solid family viewing that actually has something to say beyond 'be nice at Christmas.'

Age Fit

Common Sense Media's age 8 recommendation feels right—younger elementary kids will get the humor and heart, while tweens will appreciate the social dynamics and underdog story. Teens might find it too wholesome unless they're into nostalgic holiday feels.

WISE Breakdown

Wholesome

82

Based on the beloved children's book about 'the worst kids in town' learning empathy and disrupting a Christmas pageant, this film centers on redemption, acceptance, and finding the true meaning of Christmas. The 92% RT critic score and 97% audience score suggest emotionally resonant storytelling. Common Sense Media's age 8 recommendation indicates age-appropriate tone. The premise of misbehaving kids transforming through kindness models cooperation and second chances, though the 'worst youngsters' setup means some chaos and misbehavior will be central to the plot.

Imaginative

68

The film takes a familiar Christmas pageant and flips it with unexpected participants, which offers creative reimagining of tradition. However, it's an adaptation of a 1972 book, so the core concept isn't new. The 'mayhem and surprises' suggest some inventive moments, but this is fundamentally a heartwarming family comedy rather than a visually imaginative or world-building narrative. The comedy/drama/adventure genres hint at varied storytelling approaches, but without more detail on execution, it appears to be solidly conventional rather than boundary-pushing.

Safe

88

Common Sense Media rates this for age 8, suggesting minimal concerning content. The 'worst youngsters' premise means there will be mischief and rule-breaking behavior, but in the context of a Christmas pageant story, this is likely slapstick comedy rather than genuinely dangerous content. No MPAA rating provided, but the source material is classic children's literature. The high audience scores (97% RT) from families suggest no unexpected triggering content. Only concern is that 'worst kids' might model some poor behavior before redemption arc kicks in.

Enriching

76

The story's core message about looking past stereotypes, giving second chances, and finding meaning beyond materialism offers genuine ethical growth opportunities. The Herdman kids (the 'worst' family in town) challenging a community's assumptions creates space for conversations about judgment, poverty, and inclusion. However, it's a fairly straightforward moral tale without deep complexity. The 60 Metacritic score suggests critics found it pleasant but not particularly profound. Strong entertainment value based on audience scores, with meaningful but predictable takeaways about acceptance and Christmas spirit.

Parent Info

✓

Why It Might Be Great

97% audience score on Rotten Tomatoes means families are genuinely loving this—it hits the heartwarming notes without being saccharine
Tackles real themes like judging people by their circumstances, economic divides, and giving outsiders a chance in ways kids can understand
The Herdman kids' chaos-to-redemption arc shows that 'bad kids' often just need someone to believe in them
Fresh 2024 take on a beloved story means it's watchable for modern kids without the dated feel of older holiday films
Perfect conversation starter about how we treat people who are different or struggling

⚠

What to Watch For

The Herdman kids are intentionally portrayed as troublemakers—expect some modeling of misbehavior (lying, stealing, bullying) before the redemption arc, which younger kids might imitate
Some kids might find the 'worst family' setup mean-spirited or uncomfortable, especially if they've experienced being judged or excluded
It's a Christmas movie, so if your family doesn't celebrate or you're avoiding religious content, this centers on a church nativity pageant

Conversation Starters

"Why do you think the other kids and adults were so quick to judge the Herdmans? Have you ever misjudged someone?"
"What do you think the Herdmans needed that they weren't getting? How did people's attitudes change?"
"If you were directing the Christmas pageant, would you have let the Herdmans participate? Why or why not?"
"The movie shows that the 'worst' kids might just be misunderstood—can you think of a time when someone surprised you by being different than you expected?"

Ask Anything

Get a personalized guide on any topic

The Best Christmas Pageant Ever