The Baby-Sitters Club

The Baby-Sitters Club

show

TV-G, 2020, Kids, Adventure

WISE
84%

WISE Score

100

Avg. Tomatometer

The wholesome Netflix reboot that proves middle schoolers running a babysitting empire can still captivate in 2020—no irony required.

IMDb7.5
RT Critics100%
MC87
TMDB7.9
Common Sense Media
Where to Watch
Loading streaming options...
Screenwise Verdict

This is the rare reboot that actually works. Netflix took a beloved 80s/90s book series and updated it with contemporary diversity, modern family structures, and current social awareness—without losing the heart of what made the original special.

The show is unapologetically wholesome in an era of ironic detachment, and that's its superpower. These middle schoolers are competent, caring, and genuinely good friends to each other. They make mistakes, sure, but they talk through them like emotionally intelligent humans. It's refreshing.

The business angle gives it structure and purpose beyond just 'kids hanging out,' and each episode typically focuses on a different family's challenges, which keeps things varied. The acting is solid, the production values are Netflix-quality, and it doesn't talk down to its audience.

The main limitation? It's genuinely wholesome, which means kids seeking edge or complexity might bounce off it. And while it tackles real issues, it does so with a gentle touch that some older tweens might find too safe. But for the right kid—especially those in the 8-11 range—this is exactly the kind of positive, aspirational content that can model good friendship and responsibility without feeling like medicine.

Age Fit

This hits the sweet spot for ages 7-13, especially kids who love character-driven stories about friendship and responsibility. Younger teens might find it too wholesome unless they're nostalgic for simpler narratives or reading the original books.

WISE Breakdown
Wholesome
92

This Netflix reboot delivers exactly what you'd hope: genuine friendships, positive role models, and middle schoolers solving problems through cooperation and communication. The show tackles real issues (divorce, diabetes, family dynamics) with emotional maturity while keeping the tone warm and supportive. No mean-girl drama or cynicism—just kids being genuinely kind to each other and the families they help.

Imaginative
68

The premise itself—kids running a business—invites entrepreneurial thinking and problem-solving. Each episode presents different family situations that require creative solutions. However, it's fundamentally a grounded, realistic show rather than one that sparks fantastical imagination or hands-on creative projects. The 2020 update brings contemporary diversity and modern sensibilities to the classic formula, which shows creative adaptation if not groundbreaking originality.

Safe
95

This is about as safe as television gets. No violence, no inappropriate content, no jump scares or disturbing imagery. The show addresses real challenges (medical conditions, family separation, identity questions) but always in an age-appropriate, supportive context. Kids mode is available on Netflix. The only 'conflicts' are interpersonal misunderstandings that get resolved through conversation. Parents can confidently leave the room.

Enriching
82

Beyond entertainment, the show models entrepreneurship, responsibility, empathy, and emotional intelligence. Each babysitter has distinct personality traits and challenges (Mary Anne's shyness, Claudia's artistic struggles with school, Stacey's diabetes management, Dawn's blended family navigation) that provide rich material for character development and life lessons. The diversity and inclusion feel organic rather than preachy. Kids see examples of small business management, conflict resolution, and caring for others.

Parent Info

Why It Might Be Great

  • Genuinely positive friendships without manufactured drama or mean-girl nonsense—these kids actually like and support each other
  • Tackles real issues (chronic illness, divorce, racism, LGBTQ+ identity) with age-appropriate sensitivity and without being after-school-special preachy
  • Models entrepreneurship and responsibility in a way that feels empowering rather than didactic
  • The diversity and modern update feel authentic—this isn't your 90s BSC, and that's a good thing
  • Perfect for kids who want 'real kid' stories without needing fantasy elements or high-stakes drama

What to Watch For

  • The earnestness and wholesomeness might feel too sweet for kids who've already moved on to edgier content
  • Some episodes deal with heavier topics (family separation, medical emergencies, discrimination) that younger viewers might need context for
  • If your kid is already cynical about 'kids being nice,' they might roll their eyes—but that might be exactly why they need it

Conversation Starters

  • "Would you ever want to start a business with your friends? What would make that hard or fun?"
  • "The characters handle disagreements by actually talking about their feelings—how realistic is that with your friends?"
  • "Stacey has to manage her diabetes while doing everything else. What do you think would be hardest about having a condition you have to think about all the time?"
  • "Which babysitter would you hire and why? Which one are you most like?"
Stills
The Baby-Sitters Club — still 1
The Baby-Sitters Club — still 2
The Baby-Sitters Club — still 3
The Baby-Sitters Club — still 4
The Baby-Sitters Club — still 5
The Baby-Sitters Club — still 6

Ask Anything

Get a personalized guide on any topic

Related Guides