Our reviews and ratings are 100% unbiased. Screenwise is a Bookshop.org affiliate and an Amazon Associate, so if you buy a book through one of our links, we may earn a commission. Bookshop.org purchases also support independent bookstores.
Screenwise Verdict
This is the kind of book that sticks with you. Dashka Slater takes a headline—teen set on fire on Oakland bus—and unpacks it with the care and complexity it deserves. You get to know both Sasha (agender, white, middle-class) and Richard (Black, from the flatlands, caught in cycles of poverty and violence) as full human beings, not caricatures.
The enrichment value here is off the charts. It's a masterclass in empathy, asking readers to hold space for a victim's trauma AND a perpetrator's humanity simultaneously. The gender identity education is respectful and clear. The criminal justice critique is sharp but not preachy. Multiple awards and best-of lists confirm this is top-tier YA nonfiction.
But it's not an easy read. The violence is real, the stakes are high, and the emotional weight is substantial. This isn't for kids who aren't ready to sit with moral complexity or who might be traumatized by descriptions of burns and incarceration. For the right teen at the right time, though, this is transformative.
Age Fit
Best for ages 13+ with the emotional maturity to handle heavy content about violence, trauma, and systemic injustice. The writing is accessible, but the subject matter demands readiness for complexity and moral ambiguity. Strong choice for high school reading lists or mature middle schoolers.
WISE Breakdown
Wholesome
72
Handles heavy topics—hate crime, violence, incarceration—with empathy and nuance rather than sensationalism. Models compassion for both victim and perpetrator, showing the humanity in everyone. Doesn't shy away from tough realities of race, class, and gender, but approaches them with care. The emotional tone is mature and thoughtful, not exploitative.
Imaginative
68
Innovative narrative structure for nonfiction, weaving together two distinct lives and perspectives. Invites readers to imagine experiences outside their own—what it's like to be agender, to grow up in different Oakland neighborhoods, to navigate the justice system. The journalism is creative in its approach, but it's ultimately a true story being told rather than inviting open-ended creative exploration.
Safe
58
Contains a violent hate crime (teen set on fire), discussion of serious injuries and burns, incarceration of minors, gang violence, and systemic racism. These aren't gratuitous, but they're real and intense. Not something a younger kid should stumble into unexpectedly. The content is handled responsibly, but it's heavy material that requires emotional readiness.
Enriching
92
Exceptional educational value. Builds deep empathy by humanizing both sides of a crime. Tackles intersecting issues of race, class, gender identity, criminal justice, and restorative justice with sophistication. Award-winning journalism that gives teens (and adults) real insight into lives and systems they may not otherwise understand. Stonewall Book Award winner, multiple best-of lists. This is the kind of book that changes how you see the world.
Parent Info
✓
Why It Might Be Great
Builds genuine empathy for people on both sides of a crime—victim and perpetrator are both humanized
Tackles race, class, gender identity, and criminal justice with nuance and sophistication, not platitudes
Award-winning journalism (Stonewall Book Award, YALSA Excellence in Nonfiction) that reads like a compelling narrative
Gives teens real insight into lives they may not otherwise encounter—Oakland neighborhoods, agender identity, juvenile justice
Models restorative justice thinking and the complexity of real-world ethics
⚠
What to Watch For
Depicts a violent hate crime—teen set on fire on a bus, resulting in serious burns requiring skin grafts
Heavy themes throughout: incarceration of minors, gang violence, systemic racism, trauma
Requires emotional maturity to process the complexity of sympathizing with both victim and perpetrator
Some readers may find the gender identity content challenging depending on family values (though it's handled respectfully)
Conversation Starters
"Sasha uses they/them pronouns. What do you think about gender identity and how people choose to express themselves?"
"Richard made a terrible choice in a few seconds that changed two lives forever. How do you think about accountability vs. compassion?"
"The book shows how Sasha and Richard lived in the same city but completely different worlds. What creates those divides?"
"Do you think Richard should have been tried as an adult? What's the point of juvenile justice—punishment or rehabilitation?"
"How did reading both perspectives change how you felt about what happened?"