Our reviews and ratings are 100% unbiased. Screenwise is a Bookshop.org affiliate and an Amazon Associate, so if you buy a book through one of our links, we may earn a commission. Bookshop.org purchases also support independent bookstores.
Screenwise Verdict
Swim Team is that rare middle grade book that checks all the boxes without feeling like it's trying too hard. Yes, it's an underdog sports story—you know where it's going—but Christmas executes it with heart, gorgeous illustrations, and enough substance to justify its award recognition.
The real win here is how it weaves in heavier themes (racism in swimming, self-destructive thoughts) without becoming an After School Special. The mentorship between Bree and elderly Etta feels authentic, not manufactured, and the book trusts kids to handle conversations about historical inequity in sports access.
It's not going to revolutionize the graphic novel genre, but it doesn't need to. It's a solid, engaging read that reluctant readers will actually finish and that gives parents plenty of meaningful conversation hooks. The 4.6 Amazon rating and enthusiastic parent reviews on Common Sense Media back this up—this is the kind of book that gets passed around friend groups and actually read more than once.
Age Fit
Best for ages 8-13, right in the middle grade sweet spot. The graphic novel format makes it accessible for reluctant readers, while the themes of perseverance, racism, and self-doubt give more confident readers something to chew on. Tweens interested in sports stories or overcoming personal challenges will connect most.
WISE Breakdown
Wholesome
88
This graphic novel centers on friendship, perseverance, and overcoming fears with mentorship from an elderly neighbor. Common Sense Media notes it tackles racism and self-destructive negative thoughts in an age-appropriate way. The story models good sportsmanship, cooperation, and intergenerational relationships. The emotional tone is heartwarming without being saccharine, and the pacing balances sports action with character development.
Imaginative
72
The graphic novel format brings visual creativity to the swimming action sequences, and the story invites readers to consider conquering personal fears. However, it follows a fairly conventional underdog sports team narrative—new kid joins struggling team, gets mentorship, faces wealthy rival school, aims for championship. While well-executed, it doesn't break new ground in terms of originality or invite much creative expression beyond engagement with the story.
Safe
92
Books are generally safe, and this one has no content warnings. Common Sense Media and parent reviews confirm it's middle-grade appropriate with themes of friendship and perseverance. The racism mentioned in reviews appears to be addressed as a topic (likely related to swimming history and access) rather than graphic depictions. No violence, mature themes, or inappropriate content for the target age group.
Enriching
81
The book offers meaningful growth opportunities: confronting fears, building resilience through hard work, and understanding teamwork. The intergenerational mentorship with Etta adds depth, and the story touches on swimming history and systemic racism in sports access. Parent reviews highlight messages about overcoming fears and good sportsmanship. It's entertaining with high-action swim meet illustrations while delivering substance. The Coretta Scott King Illustrator Honor and National Book Award longlist recognition signal quality.
Parent Info
✓
Why It Might Be Great
Tackles real issues (fear of water, racism in swimming history) without being heavy-handed or preachy
The intergenerational friendship between Bree and Etta is genuinely sweet and shows mentorship done right
High-action swim meet illustrations make the sports sequences actually exciting to read
Coretta Scott King Illustrator Honor and National Book Award longlist—this isn't just feel-good fluff, it's well-crafted
Perfect bridge for kids who loved Babysitters Club graphic novels but are ready for slightly meatier themes
⚠
What to Watch For
It's a sports story with a predictable arc—scrappy team vs. wealthy prep school isn't breaking new ground
Touches on racism in swimming (historical barriers to pool access for Black communities), which is important but might prompt questions
Kids who aren't into sports stories might find the swim meet scenes repetitive, even with good art
Conversation Starters
"Bree was really scared of swimming but did it anyway. What's something that scares you but you'd like to try?"
"Why do you think Etta wanted to help Bree so much? Have you ever had a mentor or teacher who really believed in you?"
"The book mentions that not everyone had equal access to swimming pools in the past. Why do you think that was, and why does it matter?"
"Holyoke Prep has all the fancy equipment and the Manatees don't. Does having better stuff always mean you'll win?"
