Our reviews and ratings are 100% unbiased. Screenwise is a Bookshop.org affiliate and an Amazon Associate, so if you buy a book through one of our links, we may earn a commission. Bookshop.org purchases also support independent bookstores.
Screenwise Verdict
This is the real deal—award-winning middle-grade historical fantasy that doesn't talk down to kids. Jonathan Auxier (The Night Gardener) creates a genuinely original world where a chimney sweep befriends a golem made of soot, and it works beautifully.
Yes, it's dark. Victorian child labor was brutal, and Auxier doesn't sugarcoat it. But he also doesn't wallow—this is a story about resilience, found family, and the courage to be vulnerable. Nan is tough and smart and memorable, and Charlie (the golem) is both heartbreaking and delightful.
The Jewish folklore element adds cultural richness, and the way it addresses anti-Semitism feels purposeful rather than preachy. Kids who loved The Girl Who Drank the Moon or Nevermoor will dig this. Just know it's emotionally heavier than your average middle-grade adventure—more tears, more heart, more staying power.
Age Fit
Best for ages 9-13 who can handle emotionally complex historical fiction with dark themes balanced by hope. Strong readers 8+ could manage it, but the Victorian hardship and loss themes need some maturity. Upper middle schoolers will appreciate the depth.
WISE Breakdown
Wholesome
88
A deeply compassionate story that models resilience, friendship, and the courage to be vulnerable. Nan's journey from hardened orphan to someone who can accept love and connection is emotionally healthy without being saccharine. The found-family dynamic with Charlie (the golem), Toby, and Miss Bloom demonstrates kindness and loyalty. While it addresses dark historical realities (child labor, anti-Semitism, orphan exploitation), it does so with care and purpose, never gratuitously. The tone balances heartbreak with hope—'as heartbreaking as bleak midwinter and as hopeful as early spring' per Kirkus.
Imaginative
92
A golem made of soot and ash caring for a chimney sweep? That's genuinely original. Auxier blends historical Victorian London with Jewish folklore in a way that feels fresh and inventive. The premise invites wonder—the idea of a creature born from ash and fire, childlike and protective, paired with a tough-as-nails girl creates rich imaginative territory. The 'lovable monster' archetype is executed with creativity, and the world-building of 1850s London chimney-sweeping culture adds texture. Parent reviews highlight how memorable and engaging the characters are, with kids fondly remembering them long after finishing.
Safe
75
This is a book about child labor in Victorian England, so there's inherent darkness—dangerous chimney work, exploitation, a near-death chimney fire, and themes of loss and abandonment. However, it's handled with literary care rather than graphic detail. The anti-Semitism theme is addressed meaningfully but not gratuitously. No content warnings for gore, sexual content, or shocking violence appear in any reviews. The emotional weight (loss, hardship, vulnerability) might be intense for sensitive younger readers, but it's age-appropriate middle-grade fare. Common Sense Media parents recommend it for ages 9+, which aligns with the emotional maturity needed.
Enriching
90
This is a Sydney Taylor Book Award winner that tackles real historical issues—Dickensian child labor, anti-Semitism, class exploitation—without being preachy. It builds empathy for marginalized people and explores themes of found family, resilience, and the transformative power of love and friendship. Nan's character arc from closed-off survivor to someone who can be vulnerable and strong simultaneously offers genuine emotional growth lessons. The Jewish folklore element (golem mythology) adds cultural enrichment. School Library Journal gave it a starred review calling it 'stunning historical fantasy with compelling characters.' It's both entertaining and meaningful.
Parent Info
✓
Why It Might Be Great
Genuinely original premise mixing Jewish folklore with Victorian chimney-sweep history—a golem made of soot is just cool
Award-winning storytelling (Sydney Taylor winner, starred reviews) that balances emotional depth with adventure
Strong, smart female protagonist who learns that vulnerability is strength, not weakness
Tackles real historical injustices (child labor, anti-Semitism) with care and purpose, building empathy without preaching
Characters kids remember fondly long after finishing—Nan, Charlie, Toby, and Miss Bloom create a memorable found family
⚠
What to Watch For
Victorian-era darkness: dangerous chimney work, exploitation, near-death experiences, and themes of loss and abandonment
Emotional weight might be intense for sensitive kids under 9—this is heartbreak-and-hope territory
Anti-Semitism is addressed as a theme (handled meaningfully, not gratuitously, but worth knowing)
Slower, lyrical pacing typical of literary middle-grade—not a fast-paced action romp
Conversation Starters
"Why do you think Charlie was made of soot and ash specifically? What does that symbolize about Nan's life?"
"How did Nan change from the beginning to the end? What made her willing to let people in?"
"What would you do if you found a creature like Charlie? Would you be scared or curious?"
"The book talks about how kids were treated in Victorian England—how is that different from today? Why did things change?"
"What does it mean to be a 'found family' versus a biological family? Is one more real than the other?"
