Name: Screenwise
Author: Screenwise

Screenwise Verdict

The Sturniolo Triplets are YouTube royalty in the tween world—7.5 million subscribers don't lie. The brothers are genuinely likable, their sibling dynamic is affectionate, and the content is harmless enough that you won't find anything truly shocking. But let's be real: this is peak YouTube brain rot. Fast cuts, loud reactions, endless challenges, and a merch line that your kid will beg for.

It's not enriching, it's not imaginative, and it's designed to keep eyeballs glued for as long as possible. If your kid is already on YouTube, this is far from the worst they could watch—but it's also not adding much to their day beyond entertainment. Think of it as digital candy: fine in moderation, but you wouldn't want it to be the main course.

The real concern is the parasocial pull. Millions of kids feel like they 'know' these triplets, and that emotional investment translates into merch sales, tour tickets, and hours of watch time. If your kid is asking for Sturniolo hoodies or begging to go to the 'Surprise Party Tour,' it's worth a conversation about why we feel connected to people we've never met—and whether that connection is being monetized.

Age Fit

Best for tweens and early teens (10–15) who are deep in YouTube culture. Younger kids might enjoy it but won't catch the humor, and older teens will likely find it repetitive and juvenile.

WISE Breakdown

Wholesome

68

Upbeat sibling banter and challenges model positive family relationships, but the fast-paced, competitive format and mild profanity lean more toward PG-13 energy than genuinely wholesome content. The brothers' dynamic is affectionate but chaotic—lots of yelling, peer-pressure stunts, and reactive humor that mirrors typical YouTube pacing rather than thoughtful interaction.

Imaginative

42

The channel follows standard YouTube challenge and reaction formats—'Triple Tournament' competitions, midnight surprises, and fan-submitted confessions. While the triplet dynamic adds a unique angle, the content itself is derivative and doesn't invite creative thinking or exploration. It's consumption-focused entertainment with no building, making, or open-ended play.

Safe

71

Generally PG-13 with mild profanity and competitive pranks, but no graphic violence, sexual content, or genuinely disturbing material. Comments are enabled (7.5M subscribers means a massive, unmoderated fanbase), and the channel actively encourages fan interaction and promotes merchandise. The parasocial intensity and constant merch push are typical YouTube concerns, but the content itself won't shock or traumatize.

Enriching

35

Pure entertainment with minimal educational or developmental value. The brothers are likable and their sibling bond is genuine, but the content is designed for passive consumption—challenges, reactions, and stunts that don't build skills, spark curiosity, or offer meaningful takeaways. It's junk food: fun in the moment, empty afterward.

Parent Info

✓

Why It Might Be Great

Genuine sibling chemistry—the triplets clearly like each other, which is refreshing in the YouTube landscape
Harmless, high-energy fun that resonates with the tween/early-teen crowd without crossing into truly inappropriate territory
Cross-platform presence (TikTok, podcast, tour) means kids feel connected to a broader 'community'
No extreme stunts or dangerous pranks—just competitive games and midnight surprises

⚠

What to Watch For

Constant merch plugs and parasocial intensity—your kid will probably ask for Sturniolo merch
Fast editing and chaotic pacing can be overstimulating, especially for younger or more sensitive viewers
Comments section is a free-for-all with millions of fans; not a place for unsupervised browsing
Mild profanity and competitive banter—fine for tweens, but preview if your 8-year-old wants in

Conversation Starters

"What do you like about watching the triplets? Is it the challenges, the jokes, or just the vibe?"
"Do you ever feel like you 'know' YouTubers even though you've never met them? What's that like?"
"If you could design a challenge for the triplets, what would it be?"
"How do you decide what merch or products are worth buying versus just wanting because a creator promotes them?"

Ask Anything

Get a personalized guide on any topic

YouTube Channel