Our reviews and ratings are 100% unbiased. Screenwise is a Bookshop.org affiliate and an Amazon Associate, so if you buy a book through one of our links, we may earn a commission. Bookshop.org purchases also support independent bookstores.
Screenwise Verdict
Here's the thing: this is genuinely excellent YA literature. The starred reviews aren't lying—Crutcher writes with intelligence, empathy, and unflinching honesty about abuse and loyalty. It's the kind of book that stays with you.
But it's also genuinely hard. A father who burned his daughter's face. Ongoing domestic violence. A friend's silence that hides terrible secrets. This isn't trauma for shock value—it's handled with care by an author who worked in child protection—but it's still a lot.
For the right teen at the right time, this is transformative. It validates the experience of kids who've faced abuse, models what real friendship looks like in crisis, and asks important questions about courage and standing up. For a 13-year-old who's ready to engage with difficult realities, this is the good stuff.
For a kid who's not there yet? It'll be too much. Trust your gut on your teen's readiness for this level of darkness. And maybe have a conversation before handing it over about what they're walking into.
Age Fit
This is squarely for mature teens 13 and up—multiple reviewers confirm it's too heavy for younger kids. The abuse content is serious and the emotional weight is real. Not for middle schoolers unless they're exceptionally mature and you've had conversations about this kind of content.
WISE Breakdown
Wholesome
68
Models fierce loyalty and friendship between outcasts, with Eric's determination to help Sarah Byrnes showing genuine compassion. However, the story centers on child abuse, trauma, and survival—heavy emotional territory that's handled with care but isn't exactly 'feel-good.' The tone is serious and sometimes brutal, dealing with a father who burned his daughter's face. It's emotionally mature rather than chaotic, but the subject matter keeps this from scoring higher on traditional 'wholesome' metrics.
Imaginative
62
This is realistic contemporary fiction that stays grounded in the harsh realities of abuse and high school social dynamics. There's psychological complexity in unraveling Sarah Byrnes' secret and the classroom discussions about ethics, but it's not particularly imaginative in the sense of world-building or creative exploration. The 'imagination' here is more about empathy and understanding difficult situations—important, but not the kind of spark that invites kids to build or create.
Safe
45
Multiple reviews and web search results confirm this deals with serious trigger content: child abuse (a father who deliberately burned his daughter's face), domestic violence, and trauma. The StoryGraph specifically tags it with child abuse content warnings. One reviewer notes it's 'inappropriate for little kids' and recommends 13+. Another calls it 'not an easy read' and describes it as 'heart-wrenching' and dealing with 'abusive parents.' While books are generally safe in terms of platform concerns, this has significant emotional content that would be shocking and inappropriate for younger readers.
Enriching
82
This is where the book shines. Multiple starred reviews call it a 'masterpiece' and 'transcendent.' It tackles serious ethical questions about loyalty, courage, standing up to abuse, and the complexity of family relationships. The classroom discussions about contemporary ethical issues add intellectual depth. Crutcher draws on his experience as a family therapist and child protection specialist, bringing authenticity to difficult topics. It builds empathy for outcasts and survivors, and offers meaningful insights about friendship and moral courage. The book won ALA Best Book for Young Adults and the author has three lifetime achievement awards.
Parent Info
✓
Why It Might Be Great
Multiple starred reviews calling it a 'masterpiece' and 'transcendent'—this is critically acclaimed YA literature at its finest
Models fierce friendship and loyalty between outcasts, showing what it means to stand by someone through impossible circumstances
Written by a family therapist and child protection specialist, bringing authentic insight to difficult topics of abuse and survival
Includes thought-provoking classroom discussions about ethics, religion, and contemporary issues that invite real reflection
Tackles the reality that some kids face terrible situations at home, validating experiences and showing pathways to help
⚠
What to Watch For
Heavy content about child abuse—Sarah Byrnes' father deliberately burned her face as a child, and the story involves uncovering ongoing domestic violence
Emotionally intense and sometimes brutal; reviewers specifically note it's 'not an easy read' and inappropriate for younger kids
Best for mature teens (13+) who are ready to engage with serious trauma and ethical questions
May be triggering for kids with their own abuse histories—consider your teen's readiness for this level of darkness
Conversation Starters
"Eric stays loyal to Sarah Byrnes even when she goes silent. What would you do if a friend suddenly shut you out but you knew something was really wrong?"
"The book deals with a father who abused his daughter. What do you think adults should do when they suspect a kid is being hurt at home?"
"Eric and Sarah Byrnes were both outcasts—him for being fat, her for her scars. How does being an outsider change how you see other people?"
"The class has discussions about ethics and religion. Did any of those conversations make you think differently about something?"
"Sarah Byrnes is described as the 'smartest, toughest person' Eric knows. What makes someone truly tough?"
