Name: Screenwise
Author: Screenwise

Where to Watch

Loading streaming options...

Screenwise Verdict

Here's the thing: Star Trek: Picard is not for kids, and it's barely for teens. This is a show made for Gen X parents who grew up watching The Next Generation and are now confronting their own mortality.

The critics loved it (89%), but actual fans were split (57% audience score), and that tells you everything. Some appreciated the mature, darker take on beloved characters. Others felt it betrayed Trek's optimistic spirit with gratuitous violence and cynicism.

The show has genuine merit—Stewart's performance is powerful, the themes about aging and redemption resonate, and it asks important questions about consciousness and rights. But it's also got eye-gouging, F-bombs, and a level of graphic violence that would make Gene Roddenberry roll in his grave.

If you have a mature 16-17 year old who's ready for adult sci-fi and has the Trek background to appreciate the callbacks, maybe. But honestly? This is a show for the 40-something parent to watch after the kids are in bed, preferably with a glass of wine and low expectations for Season 2.

Age Fit

This is firmly adult Trek, best for 15+ and really more like 16-17+ for comfort. If your teen loved TNG, they might be ready for this, but prepare them—it's not the optimistic, family-friendly Trek of the '90s. Adults who grew up with Picard will get the most out of it, though they may be divided on whether it honors or tarnishes the legacy.

WISE Breakdown

Wholesome

65

While Star Trek generally models cooperation and moral reasoning, Picard is notably darker and more cynical than classic Trek. It deals with themes of loss, aging, regret, and institutional failure. The tone is mature and sometimes melancholic rather than uplifting. Characters model loyalty and sacrifice, but the emotional weight skews heavy for younger viewers.

Imaginative

78

Star Trek's universe remains imaginative with futuristic technology, alien species, and space exploration. Picard explores philosophical questions about AI consciousness, mortality, and what it means to be human. However, it's more character-driven nostalgia than bold new sci-fi concepts, leaning heavily on TNG callbacks rather than breaking new ground.

Safe

55

Common Sense Media rates this 15+, and for good reason. The show contains graphic violence including decapitation, eye-gouging, and disturbing body horror. There's profanity (including F-bombs, a Trek first), mature themes of trauma and PTSD, drug use, and some sexual content. The darker tone and unexpected brutality make this a hard 'no' for younger Trek fans expecting TNG-style content.

Enriching

72

Picard tackles meaningful themes: aging with dignity, redemption, the ethics of synthetic life, and standing up to corrupt institutions. It explores complex moral questions and features a diverse cast with nuanced relationships. However, the execution is uneven across seasons, with convoluted plotting that sometimes undermines its philosophical ambitions. Still offers substance for mature viewers who can engage with its themes.

Parent Info

✓

Why It Might Be Great

Patrick Stewart reprising his iconic role with gravitas and emotional depth
Tackles mature themes about aging, mortality, and what happens when heroes get old
Explores complex ethical questions about AI consciousness and synthetic life
Nostalgic reunions with TNG characters for longtime Trek fans
Diverse cast with nuanced relationships and representation

⚠

What to Watch For

Graphic violence including decapitation, eye-gouging, and body horror—way beyond typical Trek
Profanity including F-bombs (a franchise first that shocked many fans)
Dark, heavy tone dealing with trauma, depression, and institutional corruption
Convoluted plotting especially in later seasons that may frustrate viewers
The 57% audience score vs 89% critic score tells you this divided the fanbase hard

Conversation Starters

"How do you think Picard has changed since we last saw him? What does aging do to heroes?"
"The show asks whether synthetic beings deserve the same rights as humans—what do you think?"
"Why do you think the Federation became so cynical and closed-off? Can good institutions go bad?"
"How would you handle discovering you only had a limited time left to make things right?"
"Is it better to remember characters as they were, or see them grow old and flawed?"

Ask Anything

Get a personalized guide on any topic