Name: Screenwise
Author: Screenwise

Where to Find

App Store

Google Play

Screenwise Verdict

Here's the thing: Smule has genuinely good vocal development tools. The pitch tracking, key adjustment, and creative effects actually work, and kids can legitimately improve their singing. The problem is that all of this comes wrapped in an unmoderated social platform where your 11-year-old is duetting with random adults from around the world.

Parent reviews are consistent: kids encounter sexual content, drug references, and explicit language regularly. The "kids mode" is a band-aid on a platform fundamentally designed for adult social interaction. The app wants to be TikTok for singers, which means all the same risks apply.

If your kid is genuinely interested in vocal development, consider actual singing lessons, YouTube tutorials, or standalone karaoke apps without the social features. If you do allow Smule, treat it like any other social media: constant supervision, private-only mode, and regular check-ins about what they're seeing and who they're interacting with. This isn't a "hand them the iPad and let them sing" situation—it's a "sit next to them the entire time" situation.

For older teens (16+) who already navigate social media responsibly, it can be a fun creative outlet. For younger kids? The risks far outweigh the benefits.

Age Fit

Despite the 12-13+ ratings, this app is really designed for older teens and adults who can navigate social media safely. For younger kids who love singing, better options exist that don't come with open social networking risks. If you do let a tween use it, constant supervision is non-negotiable.

WISE Breakdown

Wholesome

45

While singing is inherently positive, this is an unmoderated social platform where users encounter adult content, explicit language, and sexual references. Parent reviews confirm exposure to drugs, sex, and inappropriate language. The app's community features expose kids to strangers globally without robust safeguards. The 'wholesome' singing activity is undermined by the social media dynamics and user-generated content risks.

Imaginative

72

Strong creative tools for vocal expression: pitch shifting, harmonies, effects, video creation, and collaborative duets. The reverse singing feature and layered recordings offer genuine experimentation. Users can explore 15+ million songs across genres and develop their own vocal style. However, it's primarily consumption and performance of existing songs rather than original composition, limiting true creative depth.

Safe

35

Major safety concerns dominate. This is an open social platform connecting users globally with minimal age verification. Parent reviews explicitly warn about references to sex, drugs, and explicit language in user content. While a kids mode exists, the app is fundamentally designed as social media for adults. The freemium model likely includes aggressive monetization (VIP subscriptions mentioned in search results). Unmoderated user interactions with strangers pose significant risks for children.

Enriching

58

Legitimate vocal development tools: pitch tracking, key adjustment, guided feedback, and practice features help users improve singing skills. Collaboration with global artists provides exposure to diverse musical styles. However, the social validation mechanics (likes, joins, followers) and performance pressure may undermine intrinsic learning. The app prioritizes social engagement over structured musical education, making it more entertainment platform than learning tool.

Parent Info

✓

Why It Might Be Great

Genuine vocal development tools with pitch tracking, key adjustment, and real-time feedback that can actually help kids improve their singing
Creative expression through layered recordings, harmonies, effects, and music video creation—more than just basic karaoke
Exposure to diverse musical genres and global artists, from K-pop to Broadway to contemporary pop
Confidence-building through performance practice in a lower-stakes environment than real-world singing
When used privately with supervision, can be a fun family activity for making music videos together

⚠

What to Watch For

This is essentially social media disguised as a singing app—kids are connecting with adult strangers globally with minimal moderation
Multiple parent reviews confirm exposure to sexual content, drug references, and explicit language in user performances and comments
The VIP subscription model likely creates pressure to upgrade for full features and removes ads
Kids mode exists but doesn't solve the fundamental issue that this is an open platform designed for adults
The social validation mechanics (likes, joins, followers) can become addictive and shift focus from learning to performing for approval

Conversation Starters

"What songs are you working on? Can you show me how the pitch tracking helps you hit the right notes?"
"Who are you singing duets with? Do you know these people in real life, or are they strangers from the app?"
"Have you seen any comments or videos that made you uncomfortable? What did you do about it?"
"What's the difference between practicing singing for yourself versus performing for likes and followers?"
"If we're going to use this, let's set it to private mode and only share recordings with people we actually know—sound good?"

Ask Anything

Get a personalized guide on any topic