Name: Screenwise
Author: Screenwise

Where to Play

Our reviews and ratings are 100% unbiased, but as an Amazon Associate, Screenwise earns an affiliate fee if you buy a book or game by clicking one of our links. We don't get any credit if you just Google it instead :)

Screenwise Verdict

Scythe is a legitimately excellent strategy game that happens to look like a war game but plays like an economic puzzle. The dieselpunk aesthetic is gorgeous, the faction asymmetry creates real replayability, and the strategic depth rewards careful planning over aggressive combat.

The 14+ rating is spot-on for complexity, not content. This is a 2-hour brain-burner that teaches opportunity cost, resource management, and long-term strategic thinking. Combat is actually discouraged because it's expensive and slows your engine—most games have maybe one or two battles total.

The learning curve is real. First game will be slow and potentially frustrating as players figure out the interlocking systems. But once it clicks, Scythe becomes deeply satisfying. With 91K ratings and an 8.1 on BGG, plus a shelf full of awards, this is a modern classic that's worth the investment for families who love strategic games.

Not for casual game night families. But for teens and adults who want something meatier than Catan? This is the good stuff.

Age Fit

Best for ages 14+ who enjoy complex strategy games and can handle 2-hour play sessions. The war theme is economic rather than violent. Parent reports confirm motivated 10-12 year olds can handle the mechanics, but the strategic depth really shines with teens and adults who appreciate engine-building games.

WISE Breakdown

Wholesome

72

Scythe presents an alternate-history 1920s Europa with mechs, farming, and territorial conflict. The theme is war and conquest, but the actual gameplay focuses on economic engine-building and resource management rather than gratuitous violence. The artwork (which won multiple awards) depicts a dieselpunk aesthetic with giant mechs but isn't graphic. The game models strategic thinking and planning rather than pure aggression. Parent reports on Reddit confirm kids enjoy it and the 'mature' aspect is strategic depth, not content. It's competitive but not mean-spirited.

Imaginative

88

Exceptional world-building in an alternate-history 1920s with Eastern European factions, mysterious Factory, and diesel-powered mechs. The asymmetric faction powers mean each playthrough feels different. Players build engines, manage resources, deploy mechs, and control territory—all requiring creative problem-solving and strategic planning. The award-winning artwork (won Golden Geek Best Artwork) creates an immersive dieselpunk world. The game invites players to imagine themselves as faction leaders making tough choices about expansion, economy, and military power. High replayability due to variable player powers and multiple paths to victory.

Safe

85

Board games are inherently safe, and Scythe is no exception. The conflict is abstract territory control, not graphic combat. The 14+ age rating reflects complexity (3.45 weight), not mature content. Social dynamics are competitive but fair—combat is actually rare and costly in Scythe, which discourages excessive aggression. No gambling mechanics. The game rewards long-term planning over confrontation. Parent reports confirm kids handle it well. The only 'safety' concern is potential frustration from complexity and the 2-hour play time, but that's developmentally appropriate challenge for teens.

Enriching

86

Scythe is a masterclass in strategic planning, resource management, and economic engine-building. The 3.45 complexity rating means players develop serious cognitive skills: long-term planning, opportunity cost analysis, risk assessment, and adaptive strategy. The asymmetric factions teach players to work within constraints and maximize different advantages. It won Golden Geek Best Strategy Game and Board Game of the Year for good reason. Players learn about trade-offs, timing, and reading opponents. The 115-minute play time demands sustained focus and strategic thinking. With 91K ratings and an 8.1 BGG score, it's proven to engage and challenge players intellectually.

Parent Info

✓

Why It Might Be Great

Stunning artwork and world-building—alternate 1920s with giant mechs and Eastern European factions that won multiple design awards
Teaches serious strategic thinking: resource management, long-term planning, opportunity cost, and adaptive strategy (3.45 complexity)
Combat is actually rare and costly—the game rewards clever economic play over aggression, making it less confrontational than it looks
Asymmetric factions mean every game feels fresh, with different paths to victory and unique faction abilities
Legitimate solo mode for when you want to strategize alone, plus scales well from 1-5 players

⚠

What to Watch For

The 14+ rating is about complexity, not content—expect a 2-hour game with a real learning curve that might frustrate younger or casual players
War theme might look intense with the mechs and territory control, but actual gameplay is economic engine-building (think Settlers of Catan meets chess)
This is a commitment game—if your family prefers quick 20-minute games, Scythe will feel like homework
First game will be slow as everyone learns the interlocking systems; consider watching a tutorial video first

Conversation Starters

"Which faction ability did you think was most powerful? How would you play differently next time?"
"When did you decide to avoid combat versus go for it? What made that the right call?"
"What was your strategy—did you focus on economy, territory, or a balanced approach?"
"The game is set in an alternate 1920s—what do you think would be different if mechs actually existed after WWI?"
"How did it feel when someone blocked your plan? What did you do to adapt?"

Ask Anything

Get a personalized guide on any topic