Our reviews and ratings are 100% unbiased. Screenwise is a Bookshop.org affiliate and an Amazon Associate, so if you buy a book through one of our links, we may earn a commission. Bookshop.org purchases also support independent bookstores.
Screenwise Verdict
This is the kind of middle-grade book that sticks with kids—the ones who read it in 2010 still remember their imaginary savvies. Ingrid Law nailed the magical realism sweet spot: weird enough to be memorable (talking tattoos!), grounded enough to feel real.
The family dynamics are the real magic here. The Beaumonts aren't perfect, but they're loyal and accepting in ways that model healthy relationships without being after-school-special about it. Mibs' journey from wanting a flashy power to understanding her actual gift is classic coming-of-age stuff, handled with humor and heart.
It's not dumbed down, it's not trying too hard to be cool, and it trusts kids to handle complex emotions. The writing is solid, the plot moves, and the metaphor of 'savvies' as the unique things that make us who we are lands without being heavy-handed. A decade-plus later, it still holds up—which is more than you can say for most middle-grade fiction.
Age Fit
Perfect for 9-13 year olds navigating their own emerging identities and family dynamics. The magical realism and adventure plot appeal to upper elementary and middle schoolers, while the emotional maturity and themes resonate most with tweens starting to figure out who they are.
WISE Breakdown
Wholesome
88
Strong family bonds and emotional maturity anchor this story. Mibs' motivation—saving her injured father—is pure-hearted, and the journey teaches cooperation and acceptance of differences. Mild content (one punch, brief struggle, couple of kisses) keeps it age-appropriate. The Beaumont family's quirks model embracing what makes each person unique without shame.
Imaginative
92
The 'savvy' concept—magical powers that hit at age thirteen—is wonderfully original. Talking tattoos, hurricane-causing brothers, and electricity-wielding siblings create a rich magical realism world. The rickety bus adventure and the mystery of what power Mibs will develop invite readers to imagine their own savvies and explore the creative 'what if' of inherited magic.
Safe
94
Exceptionally safe for middle-grade readers. Common Sense Media confirms mild content: one punch, brief struggle, a couple of kisses, and kids misleading adults—all standard coming-of-age fare. No graphic violence, mature themes, or content that would surprise young readers. The 'kidnapping' mentioned is part of the adventure plot, not traumatic. Multiple parent reviews emphasize positive messages and family-friendly content.
Enriching
86
Coming-of-age themes about identity, acceptance, and family loyalty provide genuine emotional growth opportunities. The metaphor of 'savvies' as talents or differences everyone must learn to manage is developmentally rich for tweens navigating their own emerging identities. Strong messages about faith, human spirit, and that our 'powers' might not be what we expect but can still be valuable. Engaging plot keeps entertainment value high.
Parent Info
✓
Why It Might Be Great
The 'savvy' concept is genuinely original—kids will immediately start imagining what their own magical power would be
Strong family dynamics that celebrate differences without being preachy about it
Adventure plot keeps pages turning while exploring real tween anxieties about growing up and fitting in
Newbery Honor recognition signals quality writing that respects young readers' intelligence
The metaphor of discovering your unique 'power' hits perfectly for the middle-grade identity crisis years
⚠
What to Watch For
The father's accident is the inciting incident—brief hospital/injury themes but not graphic or traumatic
Kids deceive adults to go on their adventure, which gets addressed but might need a conversation about why that's risky
Best for confident readers around 4th-6th grade; younger kids might struggle with pacing or vocabulary
Conversation Starters
"If you got a savvy at thirteen, what would you want it to be? What would be the hardest part about having that power?"
"Mibs wanted a savvy to save her dad, but sometimes we don't get what we want. How did she handle that disappointment?"
"The Beaumont kids all have really different powers. How is that like how siblings in real families are all different?"
"Why do you think the tattoos could talk? What do you think they represented in the story?"
