Name: Screenwise
Author: Screenwise

Where to Watch

Loading streaming options...

Screenwise Verdict

Let's be crystal clear: Sally4Ever is not for kids, not for teens, not for family movie night. This is explicit adult comedy that HBO put on their platform knowing exactly what they were doing.

That said, if you're an adult who loves dark British comedy—the kind that makes you laugh while simultaneously making you deeply uncomfortable—this might be your jam. Critics went wild for it (97%!), though regular audiences were more split (67%), which tells you everything you need to know: it's polarizing, boundary-pushing stuff.

The WISE score is low because this fails almost every metric for family-friendly content. But that's not really the point—this was never meant to be wholesome or safe or enriching in a traditional sense. It's meant to be a darkly funny exploration of a complete relationship disaster.

For Screenwise purposes: keep this far away from kids, and even as an adult, know what you're getting into. It's not 'ha ha' funny—it's 'oh god this is so awkward I can barely watch' funny.

Age Fit

This is exclusively for adults 18+. The explicit sexual content, nudity, and mature themes make it completely inappropriate for anyone younger. Even among adults, the deliberately uncomfortable tone means it's not for everyone.

WISE Breakdown

Wholesome

15

This is a dark British comedy centered on a messy, chaotic affair with heavy sexual content, dysfunction, and emotionally manipulative relationships. The tone is deliberately uncomfortable and cringe-inducing rather than emotionally healthy. Not modeling kindness or cooperation—quite the opposite.

Imaginative

62

Created by Julia Davis (known for dark, boundary-pushing British comedy), the show takes an original premise—a mid-life crisis affair—and explores it through absurdist, uncomfortable humor. It's creative in its willingness to go to extreme places, though it's more shocking than genuinely thought-provoking.

Safe

8

Common Sense Media rates this 17+, and for good reason. This is explicit adult content with graphic sexual scenes, nudity, mature themes around sexuality and relationships, and deliberately uncomfortable situations. HBO content, not remotely appropriate for children. The low score reflects that this would be highly inappropriate if a child stumbled upon it.

Enriching

35

While the show offers some dark comedy insight into identity crisis, toxic relationships, and the messiness of human desire, it's more about shock value and cringe than meaningful growth. Critics loved it (97% RT), but audiences were more divided (67%). Limited enrichment beyond 'relationships can be disasters.'

Parent Info

✓

Why It Might Be Great

If you love uncomfortable British cringe comedy (think Fleabag meets Peep Show), this delivers in spades
Julia Davis creates genuinely original, boundary-pushing comedy that critics adored (97% on RT)
Explores the messiness of identity, desire, and toxic relationships with dark humor
Short series (7 episodes) that doesn't overstay its welcome

⚠

What to Watch For

Explicit sexual content, full nudity, and graphic scenes throughout—this is HBO at its most adult
Deliberately uncomfortable, cringe-inducing tone that some viewers find brilliant and others find unwatchable
The humor is very dark and British—if you don't like awkward comedy, skip this entirely
Toxic relationship dynamics are the entire point, but they're hard to watch

Conversation Starters

"This is not a conversation starter for kids—this is adults-only content"
"For adult viewers: 'Have you ever made a major life decision in a moment of panic that spiraled completely out of control?'"
"For adult viewers: 'What makes cringe comedy work for some people and feel unwatchable for others?'"

Ask Anything

Get a personalized guide on any topic