Name: Screenwise
Author: Screenwise

Where to Watch

Loading streaming options...

Screenwise Verdict

This is Lifetime doing what Lifetime does: a competent, formulaic legal mystery elevated by a likable star. Reba brings her signature charm to a Nevada judge navigating rural justice and family drama, but the script is pure TV-movie template—suspicious death, sibling in trouble, courtroom moments, tidy resolution.

The content is solidly PG-13 territory: moderate language, a brothel-running sister, some stereotypical humor, and light violence. Nothing shocking, but enough edge that younger kids should skip it. For teens 13+ who like procedurals or are Reba fans, it's a fine watch—just don't expect anything groundbreaking.

The real issue? Even by 2023 standards, this feels like it could've aired in 2003. The 6.7 IMDb and 80% RT audience score suggest 'fine background viewing,' not 'must-watch.' If your teen is into legal dramas and you want something relatively safe, this works. But if they're used to prestige TV or even network procedurals with better writing, they'll likely find it slow and predictable.

Bottom line: harmless Lifetime fare for older kids and adults who want undemanding entertainment. Just manage expectations accordingly.

Age Fit

Best for ages 13+ who enjoy Lifetime-style legal dramas or are Reba fans. The language, adult themes (brothel subplot), and mild violence make it inappropriate for younger kids, but teens who like procedurals will find it watchable if not memorable.

WISE Breakdown

Wholesome

62

A Lifetime legal drama with a small-town Nevada setting that models determination and family loyalty, but undercut by 'plenty of strong foul language' (per Movieguide), irreverent humor, sexual jokes, and racial stereotypes. The core story of a woman stepping up as a judge is solid, but the execution leans into formulaic TV-movie territory with enough edge to keep it from being truly wholesome.

Imaginative

38

Lifetime courtroom mystery following a very standard template—suspicious judge death, sibling drama, Nevada circuit court setting. Nothing here invites creativity or curiosity; it's paint-by-numbers legal procedural with Reba's star power as the main draw. The 'rugged Nevada desert' backdrop could have been interesting but feels like window dressing for a familiar plot.

Safe

68

IMDb parents guide rates content as mild across violence, profanity, and substance use, with no sex/nudity flagged. Common Sense Media suggests age 13+. Movieguide notes 'strong foul language' and 'light boxing violence' but nothing graphic or traumatic. The brothel subplot (Kim's sister runs one) could catch parents off-guard, though it's handled within Lifetime's PG-13-ish boundaries. No major trigger warnings, but the language and thematic elements mean younger kids shouldn't stumble into this unexpectedly.

Enriching

52

Shows a woman in a position of judicial authority navigating a male-dominated rural circuit, which offers some representation value. The legal/ethical dilemmas are Lifetime-lite—present but not deeply explored. Kids might learn a bit about the justice system and rural Nevada life, but this is entertainment-first with modest takeaways. The sister-suspect dynamic raises questions about loyalty vs. justice, though the execution is more melodrama than meaningful exploration.

Parent Info

✓

Why It Might Be Great

Reba McEntire in a lead role brings warmth and star power to an otherwise standard TV movie
Shows a woman stepping into a judicial role in a rural, male-dominated circuit—some representation value
Mild mystery elements keep it moving; decent family viewing for teens who like legal procedurals
Available on multiple streaming platforms, easy to access

⚠

What to Watch For

Moderate profanity throughout (Movieguide notes 'plenty of strong foul language')
Sister character runs a brothel—handled within Lifetime boundaries but might prompt questions
Racial and sexual humor based on stereotypes; some irreverent jokes
Formulaic plotting; this is comfort TV, not prestige drama

Conversation Starters

"What do you think makes someone a good judge? Would you want that job?"
"How would you handle it if someone you loved was accused of something serious?"
"The movie shows small-town Nevada life—what surprised you about how different it is from where we live?"
"Do you think Kim made the right call when she [specific plot point]? What would you have done?"

Ask Anything

Get a personalized guide on any topic

Reba McEntire's The Hammer