Percy Jackson and the Olympians: The Lightning Thief Remake – WISE Score & Parent Review | Screenwise

Percy Jackson and the Olympians: The Lightning Thief Remake

Name: Screenwise
Author: Screenwise

movie2010

58%

WISE Score

Avg. Tomatometer

Greek gods meet American teens in this 2010 adaptation that's... fine, but the books (and the new Disney+ series) do it way better.

48%

→

Percy Jackson and the Olympians: The Lightning Thief Remake

movie

PG, 2010

58%

WISE Score

Avg. Tomatometer

Greek gods meet American teens in this 2010 adaptation that's... fine, but the books (and the new Disney+ series) do it way better.

48%

Jump to

Also rated on

48%

View →

Where to Watch

Loading streaming options...

Where-to-watch data byJustWatch

Screenwise Verdict

Here's the thing: this movie isn't terrible, but it's not great either. It's a perfectly serviceable fantasy-adventure that introduces Greek mythology and has a positive message about neurodiversity. The problem? It's been outclassed.

The 2010 film rushes through the story, flattens beloved characters, and leans heavily on dated CGI. Critics and audiences were lukewarm (48% on Rotten Tomatoes, 5.9 on IMDb), and fans of the books were vocally disappointed. Fast-forward to 2023, and Disney+ released a much more faithful, better-acted series that actually captures what made the books beloved in the first place.

So if your kid is curious about Percy Jackson, start with the books or the new series. This 2010 film is fine for a rainy afternoon if it's already on Disney+, but it's not worth seeking out. It's the cinematic equivalent of a C+: technically passing, but you know everyone could've done better.

Age Fit

Best for ages 10–14 who want mythology-meets-adventure and can handle moderate fantasy violence. Younger kids (8–9) might be fine with a parent present, but the monster scenes can be genuinely scary. Teens and adults will likely find it too watered-down and dated—the 2023 series is a better bet for older audiences.

WISE Breakdown

Wholesome

The film centers on a dyslexic, ADHD teen discovering his identity and worth, which models perseverance and self-acceptance. Themes of friendship, loyalty, and family are present throughout. However, the pacing is uneven and the tone skews more generic action-adventure than emotionally grounded—it's competent but not particularly warm or memorable in its character work.

Imaginative

Greek mythology transplanted to modern America has inherent creative appeal, and the concept of a secret camp for demigods invites curiosity. But the 2010 film executes this fairly by-the-numbers, with CGI monsters and action sequences that feel more derivative than inspired. It doesn't invite much creative thinking or exploration beyond 'cool, monsters and swords.' The books sparked far more imagination than this adaptation captured.

Safe

Rated PG for 'action violence and peril, some scary images and suggestive material, and mild language.' IMDb flags moderate violence (fantasy sword fights, monster battles), mild profanity, brief alcohol references, and moderate frightening scenes. Common Sense Media and Australian ACCM both recommend ages 10+ with parental guidance for younger kids due to scary mythological creatures and battle sequences. No sexual content, no gore, no truly shocking moments—it's designed as family-friendly adventure fare, though the monster designs and intensity may unsettle kids under 10.

Enriching

The film introduces Greek mythology in an accessible way and can spark interest in the source material (both the books and the actual myths). Percy's dyslexia and ADHD are framed as demigod traits, which is a positive reframe for neurodiverse kids. That said, the film simplifies and rushes the story, missing much of the book's depth around identity, belonging, and moral complexity. It's entertaining enough to hold attention but doesn't leave much to chew on afterward—more popcorn than protein.

Parent Info

✓

Why It Might Be Great

Introduces Greek mythology in a modern, action-packed way that might hook reluctant readers into the book series
Percy's dyslexia and ADHD are reframed as demigod superpowers—a genuinely positive message for neurodiverse kids
Straightforward hero's journey with themes of friendship, loyalty, and finding where you belong
Decent gateway for kids who want 'big kid' adventure movies but aren't ready for Marvel-level intensity

⚠

What to Watch For

Fantasy violence throughout: sword fights, monster attacks (Medusa, Minotaur, Hydra), and perilous situations that may scare kids under 10
Some scary imagery—monsters turning to stone, underworld scenes, and tense chase sequences
Mild language and brief alcohol references (nothing shocking, but present)
The film rushes through the plot and flattens characters—if your kid loves it, steer them to the books or the 2023 Disney+ series for the full story

Conversation Starters

"Percy finds out his learning differences are actually strengths. What's something about you that feels hard but might also be a superpower?"
"If you were a demigod, which Greek god or goddess would you want as your parent, and why?"
"The movie changes a lot from the book. If you've read it, what did you wish they'd kept?"
"Percy has to choose between following the rules and doing what he thinks is right. When have you had to make a tough call like that?"

Deep Dive

The "Teenager" Problem

The 2010 version of The Lightning Thief feels like a movie that was terrified of being a "kids" book adaptation. In an era where every studio wanted the next Harry Potter but with more "edge," the filmmakers made the baffling choice to age the characters up to sixteen. It sounds like a minor tweak, but it shifts the entire vibe.

Instead of a story about a kid finding his footing in a world that doesn't understand him, we get a generic teen-hero journey. The stakes feel less like a discovery of self and more like a standard action flick. If your child is a fan of the original books, this shift usually leads to immediate frustration. The movie strips away the whimsy and replaces it with a "cool" factor that feels dated and a bit desperate by today’s standards.

Action Over Essence

If you treat this as a standalone fantasy movie rather than an adaptation, it’s a mid-tier popcorn flick. The action is constant, and for a ten-year-old who just wants to see a Hydra get its heads chopped off, it delivers. However, the CGI hasn't aged gracefully. The monsters often look like they belong in a high-end video game from 2008 rather than a modern blockbuster.

The film handles Percy’s neurodiversity with a light touch, but it’s mostly used as a plot device to explain his combat reflexes. For a much more meaningful look at how the series handles these themes, our guide to Gods, Monsters, and ADHD: A Parent’s Guide to The Lightning Thief breaks down why the source material resonates so much more deeply with neurodiverse kids.

Where This Fits in 2026

We are currently living through a massive fantasy television boom, and the bar for world-building has never been higher. When you compare this movie to the more recent, faithful adaptations available on Disney+, the 2010 film feels like a fever dream from a different era. It skips over the internal logic of Camp Half-Blood and rushes Percy into a road trip that feels more like a checklist of Greek myths than a coherent story.

If you’re looking for a family movie night that actually sticks the landing, you’re better off checking our list of the Best Family Movies of 2025. This movie is strictly for the completionists or for a rainy afternoon when you’ve already exhausted every other option on the platform. It’s watchable, but in a world with so much better fantasy content, it’s rarely the right choice.

"The film's biggest sin isn't that it's bad, but that it's forgettable—a cardinal sin for a story based on legends that have lasted thousands of years." — Common Sense Media

Ask Anything

Get a personalized guide on any topic