Name: Screenwise
Author: Screenwise

Where to Watch

Loading streaming options...

Screenwise Verdict

Here's the deal: this is a well-made, thoughtful Western with Tom Hanks doing his Tom Hanks thing—quiet, decent, heroic without being showy. Critics loved it, audiences liked it, and it tackles meaningful themes about identity, belonging, and post-Civil War America.

BUT. And this is a big but. It's SLOW. Like, really, really slow. The kind of slow where modern teens raised on TikTok and Marvel will be checking their phones within 20 minutes. It's also heavy—a traumatized kid being forced from her Kiowa family back to white relatives who are strangers to her is not light viewing.

If you've got a mature teen who likes character-driven historical dramas and can handle frontier violence and complex themes, this could spark great conversations about cultural identity and what makes a family. But if you're looking for something that'll hold a middle schooler's attention on a Friday night? This ain't it. The WISE elements are solid, but the watchability factor for most modern kids is honestly pretty low.

Age Fit

Best for mature 13+ teens who can handle slow pacing, historical complexity, and heavy themes about cultural identity and displacement. Younger kids will be bored; older teens who appreciate character-driven drama will find substance here.

WISE Breakdown

Wholesome

72

Models compassion, responsibility, and cross-cultural understanding through the veteran's journey to protect and reunite a displaced child. The relationship develops authentically, showing patience and mutual respect. However, the Western frontier setting includes period-appropriate violence and moral complexity that requires maturity to process. The emotional tone is measured and thoughtful rather than manipulative.

Imaginative

58

A well-crafted period piece with strong cinematography and historical detail, but follows a fairly conventional Western road-trip narrative arc. The premise of a news reader traveling frontier towns is interesting, but the execution is straightforward rather than inventive. Doesn't particularly invite creative thinking or exploration beyond appreciating the historical setting.

Safe

55

Rated for age 13+ by Common Sense Media for good reason. Contains frontier violence including shootouts, a tense scene with a lynch mob, child endangerment situations, and the heavy theme of cultural displacement and trauma. No graphic gore or sexual content, but the violence is realistic and the emotional stakes around a traumatized child are intense. Parents need to know what they're getting into—this isn't a surprise Marvel-style action romp.

Enriching

75

Strong historical context about post-Civil War America, Native American displacement, and frontier journalism. Explores complex themes of identity, belonging, trauma, and redemption with nuance. Tom Hanks delivers a measured performance that models quiet integrity. The film rewards patient viewers with meaningful character development and ethical questions about home, family, and cultural identity. However, it's a slow burn that may not hold younger viewers' attention.

Parent Info

✓

Why It Might Be Great

Explores complex historical themes like post-Civil War reconciliation and Native American displacement with nuance and respect
Models quiet integrity, patience, and cross-cultural empathy through the evolving relationship between the two leads
Beautiful cinematography and authentic period detail that brings 1870s Texas to life
Strong critical reception (88% RT critics, 89% audience) suggests quality filmmaking that respects viewers' intelligence
Tom Hanks delivers a measured, understated performance that shows how adults can rise to unexpected responsibilities

⚠

What to Watch For

Frontier violence including shootouts, a lynch mob scene, and threats to both main characters—not graphic but realistic and tense
The entire premise revolves around a traumatized child torn from her Kiowa family and forced back into white society against her will—heavy stuff
This is a SLOW movie. Like, really slow. Modern kids raised on Marvel pacing may check out entirely
Some outdated racial attitudes from the period are depicted (though not endorsed), requiring context and discussion

Conversation Starters

"The girl was taken from the Kiowa and raised as one of them—where do you think she really belongs? Is 'home' about blood family or the people who raised you?"
"Captain Kidd reads newspapers to people who can't read. How different is that from how we get news today? Do you think people trusted news more or less back then?"
"Why do you think the Captain decided to help her even though it was dangerous and she didn't want to go?"
"What do you think happened to Native American families when their children were taken? How would that feel for everyone involved?"

Ask Anything

Get a personalized guide on any topic

News of the World