book2018Children's Books, Growing Up & Facts of Life
90%
WISE Score
4.6
Amazon
A cursed girl escapes death to compete for a spot in a magical society—Harry Potter energy with fresh originality and a heroine who doesn't know her power yet.
Nevermoor
book
2018, Children's Books, Growing Up & Facts of Life
90%
WISE Score
4.6
Amazon
A cursed girl escapes death to compete for a spot in a magical society—Harry Potter energy with fresh originality and a heroine who doesn't know her power yet.
Our reviews and ratings are 100% unbiased. Screenwise is a Bookshop.org affiliate and an Amazon Associate, so if you buy a book through one of our links, we may earn a commission. Bookshop.org purchases also support independent bookstores.
Screenwise Verdict
This is the real deal—a middle-grade fantasy that earned its Harry Potter comparisons without being derivative. Jessica Townsend built something genuinely original here: Nevermoor feels magical and dangerous and whimsical all at once, and Morrigan's journey from cursed outcast to someone worth saving is both thrilling and emotionally resonant.
The book tackles heavy themes (death, prejudice, self-worth) but keeps the tone adventurous rather than bleak. Kids who struggled with feeling different or not good enough will see themselves in Morrigan, and the fast pacing means even reluctant readers tend to stick with it.
The only real caveat: it's 2018, part of a 4-book series, and if your kid gets hooked, they'll be asking for the sequels. But that's honestly a feature, not a bug—finding a series that genuinely captivates a middle schooler is gold. This is the kind of book that reminds kids (and adults) why reading can be magical.
Age Fit
Best for ages 9-13, though confident 8-year-olds who've handled Harry Potter will likely be fine. The death curse concept and darker undertones make it a bit much for most second-graders. Upper middle schoolers will still enjoy it, but it skews younger than YA.
WISE Breakdown
Wholesome
88
Models resilience, friendship, and self-worth through Morrigan's journey from cursed outcast to finding belonging. The protagonist faces rejection and self-doubt but learns to value herself and trust others. Strong themes of loyalty, teamwork during trials, and standing up against prejudice. Some darker elements (death curse, being blamed for misfortunes) are balanced with warmth and humor throughout.
Imaginative
94
Extraordinarily creative world-building with a magical hidden city, the Wundrous Society concept, and unique magic system. Each character has distinct extraordinary talents, inviting readers to imagine their own abilities. The trials, black-smoke hounds, and Jupiter North's eccentric character create vivid, memorable imagery. Fresh take on magic that stands apart from typical fantasy tropes while maintaining accessibility for middle-grade readers.
Safe
82
Age-appropriate for middle grade with some darker themes that are handled well. The death curse and Morrigan being blamed for tragedies could be intense for sensitive younger readers, but the tone remains adventurous rather than genuinely frightening. No graphic violence, inappropriate content, or unexpected traumatic elements. The peril is fantasy-based and the protagonist escapes to safety early in the story. Common Sense Media suggests age 9+, which aligns with content level.
Enriching
86
Tackles meaningful themes of self-worth, belonging, and identity. Morrigan's insistence she has no talent while competing against obviously gifted children resonates with imposter syndrome and self-discovery. Explores prejudice, scapegoating, and how communities treat outsiders. The trial structure provides natural discussion points about perseverance, fair competition, and finding your unique strengths. Fast-paced plot keeps engagement high while delivering substance.
Parent Info
✓
Why It Might Be Great
Wildly imaginative world-building that feels fresh despite the crowded middle-grade fantasy landscape—the Wundrous Society trials and magical city of Nevermoor are genuinely creative
Morrigan is a relatable protagonist who deals with imposter syndrome and self-doubt while everyone around her seems obviously talented
Strong themes about belonging, overcoming prejudice, and discovering your worth when society has written you off
Fast-paced adventure that keeps reluctant readers engaged while delivering emotional depth and humor
Jupiter North is an eccentric, caring mentor figure who provides safety without being overbearing
⚠
What to Watch For
The death curse premise is handled adventurously but could worry anxious kids under 9—Morrigan is blamed for deaths and disasters in her town
It's book one of four, so if your kid gets hooked, you're in for the long haul (not a bad thing, just know what you're signing up for)
Some kids may find the 'I have no talent' storyline frustrating if they want a more confident protagonist from the start
Conversation Starters
"Morrigan thinks she doesn't have any special talents. Have you ever felt like everyone else was better at something than you? What happened?"
"People in Morrigan's town blamed her for bad things that weren't her fault. Why do you think people sometimes need someone to blame?"
"If you could have any 'extraordinary talent' like the kids in the Wundrous Society, what would you want it to be?"
"Jupiter North takes a huge risk to save Morrigan. Who in your life has taken a chance on you or believed in you when others didn't?"
