Our reviews and ratings are 100% unbiased. Screenwise is a Bookshop.org affiliate and an Amazon Associate, so if you buy a book through one of our links, we may earn a commission. Bookshop.org purchases also support independent bookstores.
Screenwise Verdict
This is the real deal: a National Book Award winner that tackles school violence, autism, and grief without being exploitative or saccharine. Erskine gives us Caitlin's voice with authenticity and respect—her literal interpretations, her sensory overload, her confusion when the world doesn't follow rules.
The school shooting angle will make some parents hesitate, and that's fair. But the book isn't about violence; it's about what comes after. How do you move forward when your anchor person is gone? How does a whole town heal? Caitlin's search for closure—a concept she doesn't initially understand—becomes the community's search too.
Some readers found the pacing slow, and yeah, it's deliberate. You're in Caitlin's head, processing the world the way she does. If your kid wants action and plot twists, this isn't it. But if they're ready for a character study that builds empathy and grapples with real pain? This is excellent. Just be ready to talk through the heavy stuff together.
Age Fit
Best for ages 10-14, especially kids ready for emotionally complex material. The protagonist is in elementary school, but the themes—grief, trauma, community healing—skew middle grade to early teen. Strong readers who can handle heavy emotional content will get the most from it.
WISE Breakdown
Wholesome
82
A deeply empathetic story about grief, healing, and community recovery told through the eyes of a girl with Asperger's. Models emotional growth and the search for closure after tragedy. The school shooting backdrop is heavy but handled with care, focusing on aftermath and healing rather than violence. Emotionally mature without being manipulative.
Imaginative
74
The first-person perspective from Caitlin's unique worldview—seeing things in black and white, literal interpretations—offers a genuinely fresh narrative lens. The allusions to To Kill a Mockingbird add literary depth. However, this is more character study than world-building or creative exploration. It invites empathy and perspective-taking rather than fantastical imagination.
Safe
68
Addresses serious, potentially triggering content: a school shooting that killed the protagonist's brother. While the shooting itself is off-page and the focus is on healing, the grief and trauma are central. Some readers noted 'mature themes' requiring guidance. No graphic violence, but the emotional weight is real. Parents should be prepared to support conversations about death, loss, and violence.
Enriching
88
National Book Award winner praised for fostering understanding of autism spectrum experiences and grief processing. Builds empathy for neurodiverse perspectives and explores how communities heal together. The protagonist's journey toward understanding 'closure' and navigating a world that isn't black-and-white offers genuine insight. Strong reviews highlight its emotional depth and educational value around special needs.
Parent Info
✓
Why It Might Be Great
Offers an authentic, empathetic window into how someone with Asperger's experiences the world—literal thinking, sensory details, black-and-white processing
National Book Award recognition signals genuine literary quality; critics praise it as a 'strong and complex character study'
Explores grief and community healing in a way that's honest without being gratuitous—the shooting is off-page, focus is on aftermath
Builds real empathy and understanding around neurodiverse experiences; readers consistently mention how it changed their perspective
The search for 'closure' and learning that the world has shades of gray is a genuinely moving arc
⚠
What to Watch For
The school shooting is the inciting incident—Devon's death is central to the plot. It's handled sensitively, but this is grief-heavy material that requires readiness
Some readers noted a slow start; the narrative style mirrors Caitlin's processing, which can feel deliberate
Parent reviews on Common Sense Media suggest this needs guidance for younger readers—the themes are mature even if the violence is off-page
If your kid struggles with stories about death or loss, this might hit too hard
Conversation Starters
"Caitlin sees the world in black and white at first. Can you think of times when something seemed simple but turned out to be more complicated?"
"What do you think 'closure' means? Is it something you can find, or does it just happen over time?"
"How do you think Caitlin's dad was dealing with Devon's death? What are different ways people handle grief?"
"Have you ever had to help someone understand something that was really hard to explain? What was that like?"
