Name: Screenwise
Author: Screenwise

Where to Watch

Loading streaming options...

Screenwise Verdict

Here's the thing: critics absolutely savaged this movie (42% on Rotten Tomatoes), calling it a CGI-bloated mess with cardboard characters and terrible dialogue. They're not wrong. But audiences gave it 92%, which tells you something—if you're a teen who likes war movies or has any interest in WWII history, this delivers the spectacle.

It's educational in the sense that it depicts a real, pivotal battle with attention to actual people and events. Your kid will learn something about naval warfare and the Pacific theater. But it's also exhausting—two hours of near-constant explosions, planes crashing, ships sinking, people dying. Roland Emmerich does what he does: big, loud, expensive-looking action.

The violence is pervasive but not gratuitously gory, landing squarely in PG-13 territory. Some brief gruesome moments but nothing nightmare-inducing. If your 13-year-old can handle Marvel-level action but with real historical stakes and more death, they'll be fine.

Is it a must-watch? Not really. But if you've got a history buff teen or you're looking for something to complement a WWII unit, it's serviceable. Just don't expect Saving Private Ryan or Dunkirk. This is popcorn history.

Age Fit

Best for teens 13+ who are interested in military history or war films. The constant combat and death scenes are too intense for younger kids, and adults expecting a nuanced war drama will be disappointed by the weak script and CGI overload.

WISE Breakdown

Wholesome

68

War movie that honors sacrifice and duty without glorifying violence. Shows camaraderie and leadership under pressure. The tone is respectful of the real people involved, though dialogue is reportedly weak. Models courage and teamwork, but the constant combat and death scenes make it emotionally heavy rather than uplifting.

Imaginative

52

Standard Roland Emmerich war spectacle—big explosions, CGI naval battles, but fairly by-the-numbers storytelling. It's a historical reenactment more than a creative reimagining. The 42% critic score and 2.9/5 Letterboxd rating suggest it doesn't bring much fresh perspective to the well-worn WWII genre. Serviceable but not inspired.

Safe

58

Common Sense Media confirms pervasive combat violence with explosions, bombs, and sudden deaths. Parent reviews mention 'relatively gruesome but brief scenes' and people dying throughout. Some swearing but nothing R-rated. This is exactly what you'd expect from a war movie—no surprise content, but definitely intense and violent. The PG-13 rating (implied by CSM age 13) is appropriate.

Enriching

71

Solid historical value—depicts a pivotal WWII battle with attention to real leaders and sailors. Can spark interest in naval history, strategy, and the Pacific theater. The 92% audience score suggests it resonates emotionally despite critical panning. Educational about sacrifice and the scale of WWII, though the weak dialogue limits deeper character insight.

Parent Info

✓

Why It Might Be Great

Brings a crucial WWII battle to life for teens who won't crack a history book
Shows real courage and sacrifice without making war look cool or fun
Strong audience rating (92%) suggests it connects emotionally despite critical drubbing
Good conversation starter about military strategy, leadership under pressure, and the Pacific theater
Honors the actual sailors and leaders who fought at Midway

⚠

What to Watch For

Constant combat violence—explosions, plane crashes, ships sinking, people dying throughout
Some brief gruesome moments (bodies, injuries) though not gratuitously gory
Weak dialogue and character development mean it's more spectacle than substance
Some mild swearing but nothing approaching R-rated language
The 2-hour-plus runtime and relentless battle scenes can feel exhausting

Conversation Starters

"What do you think it was like to be a pilot landing on an aircraft carrier in the middle of a battle?"
"Why was the Battle of Midway considered such a turning point in the war?"
"How do you think the code-breakers' work changed the outcome of the battle?"
"What would you have done if you were one of the leaders making decisions with incomplete information?"
"How is this version different from what you've learned about WWII in school?"

Ask Anything

Get a personalized guide on any topic

Midway