Name: Screenwise
Author: Screenwise

Where to Play

Our reviews and ratings are 100% unbiased, but as an Amazon Associate, Screenwise earns an affiliate fee if you buy a book or game by clicking one of our links. We don't get any credit if you just Google it instead :)

Screenwise Verdict

Letters from Whitechapel is a genuinely clever deduction game with a premise that'll make some parents pause: one player is Jack the Ripper, hunting victims through Victorian London while everyone else tries to catch them. Here's the thing—it's handled tastefully. No gore, no graphic cards, just strategic movement on a map. But you're still roleplaying a serial killer, so let's not pretend that's not heavy.

The gameplay itself is excellent. The hidden-movement mechanics create real tension, and the asymmetric design (one vs. many) is brilliantly executed. Detectives must cooperate and think logically; Jack must plan, misdirect, and remember their moves. It's a proper mental workout that rewards strategic thinking.

The 14+ rating is right. Younger teens who can separate historical theme from gameplay and won't be disturbed by the premise will get a lot out of this. It's not for every family, and that's fine. But if your household can handle mature themes in an abstract, strategic context, this is a solid, well-designed game with strong replayability. Just know what you're getting into.

Age Fit

Best for ages 14+ given the mature historical subject matter—one player roleplays a serial killer. Teens who enjoy strategic deduction games and can handle dark themes will find this compelling. The gameplay is abstract enough to avoid being disturbing, but the premise requires maturity.

WISE Breakdown

Wholesome

55

This is a cooperative deduction game where players work together to stop a serial killer, but one player literally plays Jack the Ripper murdering victims. The theme is dark—Victorian-era serial murder—though the gameplay is abstract (no graphic imagery, just movement on a map). The cooperative element for detectives is positive, but the core premise of roleplaying a historical murderer hunting victims is inherently grim. It's mature thematically but handled with restraint in execution.

Imaginative

78

Clever hidden-movement deduction mechanics that create genuine tension and strategic depth. Playing as Jack requires creative thinking about misdirection and memory; detectives must collaborate and reason through possibilities. The asymmetric gameplay (one vs. many) is inventive, and the cat-and-mouse dynamic generates memorable moments. BGG weight of 2.64 indicates solid strategic complexity without being overwhelming. The historical London 1888 setting is atmospheric, though not deeply explored beyond the map.

Safe

72

For board games, safety focuses on social dynamics and age-appropriate themes. The Jack the Ripper subject matter is mature (14+ rating appropriate), but the game itself is abstract—no graphic cards, no disturbing imagery, just strategic movement. Social dynamics are generally healthy: cooperation for detectives, and the tension is game-driven rather than creating personal conflict. The theme might be uncomfortable for some families, but it's handled tastefully. No gambling mechanics, no toxic elements. Biggest concern is simply the mature historical subject matter.

Enriching

74

Strong deductive reasoning, spatial thinking, memory skills, and cooperative strategy for detective players. Playing Jack teaches asymmetric thinking and planning under pressure. The historical setting offers a window into Victorian London (though not deeply educational). The game rewards careful analysis, communication, and logical deduction. 90-150 minute playtime means sustained engagement. With 25K+ community owners and 7.3 BGG rating from 17K reviews, it has proven staying power and replayability. Not life-changing, but solid cognitive workout.

Parent Info

✓

Why It Might Be Great

Brilliant asymmetric gameplay: one player vs. the group creates genuine tension and memorable moments
Detective players must cooperate, communicate, and use deductive reasoning to narrow down Jack's location
Playing as Jack is a fascinating mental challenge—misdirection, memory, and staying one step ahead
Abstract enough that the dark theme doesn't overwhelm; it's strategic movement, not graphic content
Strong replayability with 25K+ owners and consistently high ratings (7.3/10 on BGG)

⚠

What to Watch For

The theme is genuinely dark—you're literally playing a serial killer or hunting one. Not for families uncomfortable with that premise
14+ rating is spot-on; younger teens need maturity to handle the subject matter
Long playtime (90-150 min) and medium complexity means this isn't a casual weeknight game
Playing Jack can feel isolating—it's you against everyone, which some players love and others find stressful

Conversation Starters

"When you're playing as the detectives, how do you decide where to search next? What clues help you narrow it down?"
"Does playing Jack feel stressful or exciting? What's your strategy for throwing the detectives off your trail?"
"Why do you think people are fascinated by historical mysteries like Jack the Ripper? What makes this era interesting?"
"How does it feel when the detectives are closing in on you—or when you're Jack and manage to escape?"
"What other historical events or time periods would make interesting board game settings?"

Ask Anything

Get a personalized guide on any topic