Jerrod Carmichael: Rothaniel – WISE Score & Parent Review | Screenwise

Jerrod Carmichael: Rothaniel

Name: Screenwise
Author: Screenwise

movie2022

62%

WISE Score

100

Avg. Tomatometer

Jerrod Carmichael strips away the jokes to deliver a raw, intimate coming-out story that's more therapy session than comedy special.

7.9/10

100%

→

Jerrod Carmichael: Rothaniel

movie

NR, 2022

62%

WISE Score

100

Avg. Tomatometer

Jerrod Carmichael strips away the jokes to deliver a raw, intimate coming-out story that's more therapy session than comedy special.

7.9

100%

Jump to

Also rated on

7.9/10

100%

View →

Where to Watch

Loading streaming options...

Where-to-watch data byJustWatch

Screenwise Verdict

Look, this isn't for your kids—full stop. But for adults, especially those interested in the evolution of comedy and storytelling, Rothaniel is fascinating.

Carmichael essentially uses the standup format to come out publicly and process family trauma in real-time. It's uncomfortable, brave, and not particularly funny in the traditional sense. The 100% critic score isn't hype—this is genuinely groundbreaking work that expands what the medium can be.

That said, it's niche. If you want to laugh and unwind, watch something else. If you want to witness someone's raw truth-telling and think deeply about identity, family, and authenticity, this delivers. Just know you're signing up for emotional labor, not escapism.

Age Fit

This is strictly for adults 18+. The mature themes, emotional weight, and likely language make it inappropriate for teens and younger viewers, despite the important cultural conversations it sparked.

WISE Breakdown

Wholesome

This is raw, vulnerable standup that explores Carmichael's coming out and family secrets. It's emotionally honest rather than wholesome in the traditional sense—there's pain, tension, and complicated family dynamics. Not toxic, but definitely not modeling cooperation or kindness in a feel-good way. It's real life, messy and human.

Imaginative

Carmichael's stripped-down approach at the Blue Note—intimate setting, no flashy production—is itself a creative choice. The special breaks standup conventions with its confessional, almost therapeutic tone. It's original in format and delivery, inviting viewers to think differently about what comedy can be. Strong critical reception (100% RT critics, 4.2 Letterboxd) suggests genuine artistic merit.

Safe

This is an adult standup special with mature themes including sexuality, family trauma, and likely strong language (typical HBO comedy special). The coming-out narrative and discussion of family secrets could be emotionally heavy. Without an official rating listed, but given it's HBO and the subject matter, this is clearly not safe for children. Not unsafe in a predatory way, just age-inappropriate content.

Enriching

Highly enriching for adult audiences. The special offers profound insight into identity, family dynamics, Black queer experience, and the courage required for authenticity. It's more than entertainment—it's a cultural moment that sparked conversations about vulnerability and truth-telling. The 7.8 IMDb and 85% audience score suggest it resonates and provides meaningful takeaways.

Parent Info

✓

Why It Might Be Great

Groundbreaking vulnerability—Carmichael's honesty about his sexuality and family creates a powerful cultural moment
Perfect 100% on Rotten Tomatoes with strong audience scores suggests genuine artistic achievement
Challenges what standup can be—intimate, confessional, therapeutic rather than punchline-driven
Offers meaningful insight into identity, family dynamics, and the Black queer experience
Shot at the legendary Blue Note Jazz Club with stripped-down production that amplifies intimacy

⚠

What to Watch For

This is absolutely adults-only—mature themes about sexuality, family trauma, and likely strong language throughout
It's emotionally heavy and might be uncomfortable viewing even for adults—more cathartic than fun
Not traditional standup comedy—if you're expecting laugh-a-minute, this will disappoint
The confessional nature means discussing real family members and painful personal history

Conversation Starters

"What did you think about how Carmichael chose to share such personal information so publicly?"
"How do you think his family might have felt watching this? Is there a right way to tell your story when it involves others?"
"The special barely has traditional 'jokes'—did you still consider it comedy? What makes something comedy versus just storytelling?"
"What does it say about our culture that this kind of vulnerability is now celebrated rather than hidden?"

Ask Anything

Get a personalized guide on any topic