Name: Screenwise
Author: Screenwise

Where to Read

Amazon

Barnes & Noble

Libby

Our reviews and ratings are 100% unbiased, but as an Amazon Associate, Screenwise earns an affiliate fee if you buy a book or game by clicking one of our links. We don't get any credit if you just Google it instead :)

Screenwise Verdict

Look, Iron Flame is wildly popular for a reason—it's a page-turner with dragons, romance, and high stakes. But let's be clear: this is adult fantasy romance wearing a YA jacket. The violence is graphic (torture, anyone?), the sex is explicit, and the whole vibe is dark.

If you have an older teen (17+) who's already into fantasy romance and can handle Game of Thrones-level content, they'll probably devour this. The 4.7 Amazon rating reflects genuine reader enthusiasm. But if your 13-year-old grabs this because 'dragons are cool,' you're going to have an awkward conversation.

The protagonist's disability representation is actually solid, and themes about using intelligence over brute force have merit. But they're wrapped in so much graphic content that the developmental benefits get buried. This is entertainment first, enrichment distant second.

Bottom line: Great for mature readers who know what they're getting into. Not appropriate for the middle school crowd, no matter how much they beg.

Age Fit

This is firmly adult fantasy romance despite being marketed as YA. The graphic violence and explicit sexual content make it appropriate for mature 17+ readers or young adults. Younger teens drawn in by dragon covers will encounter content well beyond typical YA boundaries.

WISE Breakdown

Wholesome

45

This sequel leans heavily into brutal violence, torture, and a morally gray war college setting where 'losing your humanity' is the explicit theme. While there are themes of loyalty and determination, the tone is dark and violent throughout, with people being killed, tortured, stabbed, bones breaking, and necks snapping. The relationship dynamics include power imbalances and betrayal threats. Not emotionally healthy for younger readers.

Imaginative

78

Dragon riders, war colleges, fantasy world-building with hidden secrets spanning centuries—the Empyrean series delivers solid epic fantasy imagination. The concept of riders bonding with dragons and making their own rules invites readers into a richly constructed world. Action-packed pacing keeps readers engaged. Loses some points for being fairly derivative of recent fantasy romance trends rather than groundbreaking.

Safe

35

Common Sense Media confirms 'plenty of violence' including torture, killing, stabbing, breaking bones, and snapping necks. The fantasy setting may soften the impact slightly, but this is graphic content. The series is known for explicit sexual content (romance genre conventions), and the second book continues this pattern. A young reader picking this up unexpectedly would encounter mature violent and sexual content well beyond typical YA fare.

Enriching

62

Themes of perseverance, using intelligence over physical strength, and challenging authority offer some developmental value. Violet's determination despite physical limitations models resilience. However, the emphasis on brutal competition, 'losing humanity,' and survival-at-all-costs undermines deeper ethical growth. Primarily entertainment-focused rather than meaningfully enriching. The romance elements dominate over substantive character development.

Parent Info

✓

Why It Might Be Great

Action-packed from start to finish with compelling world-building around dragon riders and war colleges
Protagonist who uses intelligence and determination to overcome physical limitations—good representation of disability
Explores themes of challenging authority and making your own rules in oppressive systems
High reader engagement (4.7 Amazon rating) means teens who are ready for it will be hooked
Part of a larger series that rewards invested readers with payoffs and revelations

⚠

What to Watch For

Graphic violence throughout: torture, killing, stabbing, bones breaking, necks snapping—this isn't sanitized fantasy combat
Explicit sexual content between main characters (it's fantasy romance, emphasis on both words)
Dark psychological themes about 'losing your humanity' and survival at any cost
The Reddit thread about someone buying this for a 10-year-old tells you everything—this is NOT middle grade despite the dragon appeal
Long book (600+ pages) with intense pacing that may feel overwhelming for less experienced readers

Conversation Starters

"Violet wins through strategy rather than strength—when have you had to use your brain to solve a problem you couldn't muscle through?"
"The book explores what happens when systems are designed to break people down—what would you do if you were in a school that seemed designed to make you fail?"
"The dragons choose their riders—if you could bond with any kind of magical creature, what would you want and why?"
"There's a lot of moral complexity here about when breaking rules is justified—how do you decide when to follow authority versus challenge it?"

Ask Anything

Get a personalized guide on any topic

Iron Flame: The Empyrean, Book 2 Rebecca Yarros