Name: Screenwise
Author: Screenwise

Where to Watch

Loading streaming options...

Screenwise Verdict

Let's be clear: this is not something you're putting on for family movie night, or even for your high schooler unless they're specifically interested in criminal justice or psychology and can handle genuinely disturbing content.

I Just Killed My Dad is a serious, heavy documentary about a horrific situation—a teenager who endured years of brutal abuse and ultimately killed his father. It's handled with empathy and care, but the subject matter is deeply traumatic throughout. The Metacritic score of 73 suggests it's well-made, but the IMDb 6.8 and Letterboxd 3.3 tell you what you need to know: this is hard to watch.

For the right adult viewer—someone interested in true crime, criminal justice reform, or the psychology of abuse—it offers valuable insight. But it's not enriching in a feel-good way; it's enriching in a 'this is a dark corner of human experience that deserves understanding' way.

Bottom line: This earns a low WISE score not because it's poorly made, but because it's genuinely inappropriate for the vast majority of viewers, including most teens, and it's emotionally exhausting even for adults. If you're considering this for anyone under 18, the answer is almost certainly no.

Age Fit

This is strictly for adults, realistically 17+ at the absolute youngest, and even then only for emotionally mature viewers who can handle graphic discussions of child abuse and patricide. This is not entertainment—it's a difficult, heavy documentary about real trauma.

WISE Breakdown

Wholesome

25

This true-crime documentary explores patricide, severe child abuse, and deeply traumatic family dynamics. While it handles Anthony Templet's story with empathy, the subject matter—years of psychological and physical abuse leading to a fatal shooting—is inherently dark and emotionally heavy. Not emotionally healthy viewing for most audiences, especially younger viewers.

Imaginative

40

As a documentary, it offers investigative storytelling and psychological exploration of a complex real-life case. It invites viewers to think critically about justice, trauma, and family dynamics. However, it's constrained by its true-crime format and doesn't encourage creative expression or open-ended exploration—it's more observational than participatory.

Safe

20

This is definitively NOT safe content for children or even most teens. It contains graphic discussions of child abuse, domestic violence, a fatal shooting, and intense psychological trauma. Common Sense Media rates it 15+, but even that feels young. The content includes trigger warnings for abuse, violence, and death. While Netflix Kids Mode would block this, it's fundamentally unsafe for younger audiences due to its deeply disturbing subject matter.

Enriching

65

For mature viewers (17+), this documentary offers genuine insight into cycles of abuse, the criminal justice system's handling of abuse victims who become perpetrators, and the psychological impact of long-term trauma. The Metacritic score of 73 suggests critical appreciation for its thoughtful approach. It can foster empathy and understanding of complex social issues. However, it's more informative than transformative, and the entertainment value is limited—it's heavy, difficult viewing.

Parent Info

✓

Why It Might Be Great

Offers a nuanced look at how severe childhood abuse can lead to tragic outcomes, fostering empathy for victims caught in impossible situations
Explores important questions about the justice system's treatment of abuse victims who commit violence
Handles a deeply sensitive subject with care and psychological depth (Metacritic 73 suggests critical respect)
Can spark meaningful conversations about recognizing and intervening in abusive situations

⚠

What to Watch For

Graphic discussions of years of child abuse—physical, psychological, and emotional torture
The central event is a fatal shooting; while not gratuitously shown, the violence and its aftermath are discussed in detail
Extremely heavy emotional content that can be triggering for anyone with trauma history
This is NOT a 'fun' true-crime doc—it's deeply sad and disturbing throughout
Common Sense Media says 15+ but honestly, 17+ is more realistic for emotional maturity needed

Conversation Starters

"What do you think about how the justice system should handle cases where abuse victims fight back?"
"How do you think long-term trauma affects someone's ability to make decisions?"
"What are the warning signs of abuse that people around Anthony might have missed—or ignored?"
"Do you think there's ever a 'right' response when someone is trapped in an abusive situation?"

Ask Anything

Get a personalized guide on any topic