Our reviews and ratings are 100% unbiased. Screenwise is a Bookshop.org affiliate and an Amazon Associate, so if you buy a book through one of our links, we may earn a commission. Bookshop.org purchases also support independent bookstores.
Screenwise Verdict
This is a tool, not a tale. It's the book you reach for when your kid asks why their classmate has two names, or when you want to proactively teach acceptance before questions even come up. Jazz's story is told with care and simplicity—no drama, no heavy-handedness, just a kid explaining who she is.
The trade-off? It's not particularly fun to read. There's no narrative arc, no memorable characters beyond Jazz herself, no clever wordplay or illustrations that make you want to read it again and again. One reviewer nailed it: "It doesn't have a fun story." It's more like a very gentle FAQ in picture book form.
But for families who want to normalize transgender identity early, or for classrooms building inclusive libraries, this book does exactly what it sets out to do. The 4.8 Amazon rating suggests it resonates with the people who need it most. Just know you're buying an educational resource that happens to be a picture book, not a picture book that happens to be educational.
Age Fit
Best for ages 4-8, the core picture book audience. Younger kids can grasp the basic message of acceptance, while older elementary kids can engage with deeper questions about identity. Teens and adults won't find this interesting unless they're specifically looking for a resource to share with younger kids.
WISE Breakdown
Wholesome
88
Straightforward, age-appropriate picture book that models acceptance, family support, and being true to yourself. Jazz's story is told without drama or sensationalism—just a kid who knows who she is and a family that learns to support her. Emphasizes kindness, understanding, and celebrating differences in a gentle, affirming way.
Imaginative
52
This is a biographical picture book focused on explaining a real experience clearly rather than sparking creative play or exploration. It's educational and informative, but doesn't invite much imaginative engagement—no fantastical elements, no world-building, no open-ended storytelling. It's designed to teach, not to inspire pretend play or creative thinking.
Safe
92
Completely safe for the picture book audience. Uses simple, child-friendly language to explain gender identity without any mature content, violence, or scary elements. No surprise content—it's exactly what it says on the cover. The only consideration is that some families may have strong views about discussing transgender identity with young children, but the book itself contains nothing inappropriate or triggering.
Enriching
81
Provides valuable exposure to diversity and builds empathy for kids who are different. Opens conversations about identity, acceptance, and supporting others. Helps transgender kids feel seen and helps all kids understand that people can be different in many ways. The 4.8 Amazon rating and endorsements from educators and advocates signal real impact. It's educational and meaningful, though not particularly entertaining as a story.
Parent Info
✓
Why It Might Be Great
Provides essential representation for transgender kids who rarely see themselves in children's books
Uses simple, clear language that young children can understand without being talked down to
Models family acceptance and support in a way that feels warm and affirming
Opens age-appropriate conversations about identity, differences, and being true to yourself
Endorsed by educators and advocates as an important tool for building empathy and understanding
⚠
What to Watch For
This is an educational book first, entertaining story second—don't expect a plot with tension or humor
Requires family alignment on discussing transgender identity with young children
Some kids may have questions afterward that need thoughtful follow-up conversations
Works best as a conversation starter rather than a standalone read
Conversation Starters
"What makes Jazz happy? What makes you feel like yourself?"
"How did Jazz's family help her when she was confused?"
"Do you know anyone who is different from other kids? How can we be good friends to people who are different?"
"What would you do if a friend told you they felt like Jazz does?"