Name: Screenwise
Author: Screenwise

Where to Read

Amazon

Barnes & Noble

Libby

Our reviews and ratings are 100% unbiased, but as an Amazon Associate, Screenwise earns an affiliate fee if you buy a book or game by clicking one of our links. We don't get any credit if you just Google it instead :)

Screenwise Verdict

This is thoughtful, provocative dystopian fiction that doesn't pull punches. Kira's world is harsh—she's orphaned, physically disabled, and facing a society that literally wants to throw her away. Lowry doesn't sugarcoat the cruelty, which makes the book powerful but also emotionally demanding.

The disability representation is genuinely good: Kira is resourceful, talented, and complex, not inspiration porn. Her twisted foot is central to the plot but doesn't define her entire character. The celebration of creativity and craft—her weaving as almost magical—is lovely.

That said, this isn't The Giver 2.0. Some readers find the plot harder to follow and less gripping. It's more meditative and mysterious, which some kids will love and others will find slow. The opening chapters hit hard with grief and vulnerability, so sensitive readers might struggle.

If your middle schooler likes books that ask hard questions and don't tie everything up neatly, this delivers. If they want action and clear resolutions, they might be frustrated. Solid choice for the right reader, but not universally beloved like its predecessor.

Age Fit

Best for ages 11-15 who can handle emotionally heavy dystopian fiction with themes of death, disability discrimination, and social cruelty. Younger readers who loved The Giver might be ready, but the intensity and moral complexity require maturity.

WISE Breakdown

Wholesome

72

Models determination, resilience, and self-acceptance through Kira's journey. She faces hostility with grace and uses her creative gifts to survive. The community is harsh and values conformity over compassion, which creates moral complexity rather than simple good-vs-evil dynamics. Some intensity in early chapters with grief rituals and a mother's death, plus the society's treatment of the physically disabled is disturbing but thought-provoking.

Imaginative

78

Lowry constructs a distinct dystopian society with its own rules, hierarchies, and mysteries. Kira's 'almost magical' talent for weaving and embroidery is central to the plot and celebrates creative expression. The world-building invites readers to question social structures and imagine alternatives. Part of the acclaimed Giver Quartet, known for provocative speculative fiction that challenges readers to think beyond their own reality.

Safe

68

No graphic violence, sexual content, or inappropriate language. However, the opening chapters deal with death and grief rituals with some emotional intensity. The society's treatment of disabled and weak individuals is disturbing—Kira faces hostility and potential abandonment because of her twisted foot. Themes of social Darwinism and rejection are heavy for younger readers. No surprise content, but the emotional weight and darker themes require maturity.

Enriching

82

Challenges readers to examine values around community, creativity, conformity, and what makes someone valuable. Kira's physical disability and her society's response spark conversations about ableism and human worth. The mysteries within her world encourage critical thinking. Common Sense Media parents praise themes of perseverance and self-acceptance. Lowry's 'singular vision of a future' inspires contemplation long after reading. Some parents note the plot can be difficult to follow, which may frustrate some readers.

Parent Info

✓

Why It Might Be Great

Protagonist with a physical disability who's resourceful, talented, and refuses to be discarded—representation that goes beyond tokenism
Raises genuine ethical questions about conformity, creativity, and what makes someone 'valuable' to a community
Part of Lois Lowry's acclaimed Giver Quartet, so if your kid loved The Giver, this continues that thoughtful dystopian tradition
Celebrates creative expression and craft—Kira's weaving is portrayed as almost magical and central to her survival
Inspires real conversation about disability, social structures, and acceptance without being preachy

⚠

What to Watch For

Opens with death and grief rituals—Kira's mother has just died and she's immediately vulnerable and alone
The society is genuinely harsh: they want to discard Kira because of her twisted foot, neighbors are hostile, weakness is punished
Some parents note the plot is hard to follow and lacks depth compared to The Giver—not every kid will connect with the pacing
Heavy emotional themes throughout—this isn't a light read, it's meant to provoke and unsettle

Conversation Starters

"Why do you think Kira's community treats people with disabilities the way they do? What would you do differently?"
"If you had a special talent like Kira's weaving, what would it be? How could it help you or your community?"
"The Council has mysterious plans for Kira. Do you think they're trying to help her or use her? What clues did you notice?"
"How is Kira's world different from the one in The Giver? What do both societies get wrong about people?"

Ask Anything

Get a personalized guide on any topic

Gathering Blue