Our reviews and ratings are 100% unbiased. Screenwise is a Bookshop.org affiliate and an Amazon Associate, so if you buy a book through one of our links, we may earn a commission. Bookshop.org purchases also support independent bookstores.
Screenwise Verdict
Gathering Blue is the quiet middle child of the Giver Quartet, and it deserves more credit. While it’s technically a sequel, it feels like a standalone story about a girl trying to stay human in a place that treats people like tools.
It’s not an 'action' book. It’s a 'thinker' book. If your kid liked The Giver, they’ll appreciate the shift to this more primitive, colorful, and slightly more dangerous world. It’s from 2000, but the themes of how we treat the 'flawed' among us feel more relevant than ever.
Just be ready for a 'wait, that's it?' ending—Lowry loves to leave the door open for the next book.
Age Fit
Best for ages 10 to 14. Younger kids might find the 'discarding' of people too scary, while older teens might find the plot a bit simple compared to modern dystopian trilogies.
WISE Breakdown
Wholesome
76
The story centers on a protagonist who chooses empathy and creation in a culture that rewards brutality. It's not 'feel-good'—the society is actually pretty horrific—but the moral core is rock solid.
Imaginative
90
Lois Lowry builds a primitive, post-apocalyptic world that feels tactile. The way she uses the art of dyeing and weaving as a metaphor for history and the future is genuinely unique.
Safe
82
No sex or graphic gore, but the premise is heavy: a society that 'discards' (kills) the disabled and elderly. It's handled with literary weight, not for cheap shocks.
Enriching
94
It forces kids to think about how we treat the vulnerable and the role of art in society. It's basically a masterclass in ethics for middle schoolers.
Parent Info
✓
Why It Might Be Great
Kira is a refreshing protagonist who wins with her brain and her hands, not a bow and arrow.
The 'Singer’s Robe' is a cool concept that makes history feel like something you can actually touch.
It’s a great 'bridge' book for kids who are moving from simple adventure stories to complex social commentary.
Lowry doesn't talk down to her readers; she trusts them to handle a world that isn't fair.
⚠
What to Watch For
The 'Field of Leaving' is where the sick and disabled are left to die—it's a dark concept for more sensitive kids.
The pacing is slower than modern YA like The Hunger Games. There are no explosions, just high-stakes weaving.
Characters are casually mean to each other; the village is built on a 'survival of the fittest' mindset that can be depressing.
Conversation Starters
"Why is this village so afraid of people who are different or 'weak'?"
"If you had to weave the story of our world today onto a robe, what colors and scenes would you use?"
"Do you think Kira is safer inside the Council Edifice or out in the village?"
"Is it better to have a perfect society with no pain (like in The Giver) or a messy, hard society where you're free to create?"
