Name: Screenwise
Author: Screenwise

Where to Watch

Loading streaming options...

Screenwise Verdict

Look, let's be real: Fireproof is not a good movie by any conventional filmmaking standard. The 38% critic score isn't critics being mean to Christians—it's because the acting is wooden, the production is cheap, and the script beats you over the head with its message.

That said, if you're in a faith-based family, this film has probably already been recommended to you seventeen times. It does have a sincere, positive message about commitment and working through hard times. The 82% audience score shows it genuinely resonates with its intended audience.

The problem for Screenwise purposes? It's nearly unwatchable for anyone outside that specific demographic, and even within it, it's dated and amateurish by 2025 standards. If you want your teens to think about relationships and commitment, there are better-made films that don't feel like a church basement production. But if you're specifically looking for faith-based content and can overlook the quality issues, the heart is in the right place.

Age Fit

Best for teens 13+ who can handle relationship drama and won't be put off by the overt religious content. Adults in faith communities are the real target audience. Kids under 12 will be bored senseless.

WISE Breakdown

Wholesome

72

Models commitment, sacrifice, and working through relationship difficulties rather than giving up. Emphasizes communication and personal growth within marriage. However, the heavy-handed religious messaging and somewhat dated gender dynamics prevent a higher score. The film does genuinely promote kindness and perseverance.

Imaginative

28

Straightforward faith-based drama with minimal creative vision. The 'Love Dare' concept provides some structure but it's formulaic Christian cinema with predictable beats. Low production values and uninspired cinematography. Letterboxd's 2.5/5 and Metacritic's 28 reflect the lack of artistic ambition.

Safe

85

CSM rates it 12+, suggesting minimal concerning content. Marriage conflict and relationship tension are the primary issues, but no violence, gore, sexuality, or shocking content. The drama is emotionally intense but predictable and age-appropriate for tweens and up.

Enriching

55

Does tackle important themes of commitment, personal accountability, and relationship repair. The 40-day challenge framework could spark meaningful conversations about marriage and perseverance. However, the preachy delivery, amateur acting, and simplistic solutions undermine its potential impact. The 82% RT audience score suggests it resonates with its target demographic, but the 38% critic score reflects its limited artistic merit.

Parent Info

✓

Why It Might Be Great

Genuinely pro-commitment message about working through marriage difficulties instead of bailing
The '40-Day Love Dare' framework could spark real conversations about relationships and sacrifice
Shows a firefighter dealing with real-world temptations and personal flaws, not just being a hero
If you're in a faith community, this is a shared cultural touchstone that many families have seen and discussed

⚠

What to Watch For

This is Christian cinema with a capital C—expect Bible verses, prayer scenes, and conversion moments as plot points
Production quality is community theater level; if your kids are used to Marvel budgets, this will feel painfully low-rent
Some traditional gender role dynamics that may not align with your family's values
It's earnest to the point of cringe—the sincerity is real but the execution is rough

Conversation Starters

"What do you think makes a relationship strong enough to last?"
"The movie shows the husband doing nice things for 40 days—do you think that's realistic or just movie magic?"
"Have you ever had to work really hard to fix a friendship? What did you do?"
"Why do you think the critics hated this but regular audiences loved it?"

Ask Anything

Get a personalized guide on any topic