Eliza and Her Monsters

Eliza and Her Monsters

book

2019, Teen & Young Adult, Literature & Fiction

WISE
78%

WISE Score

4.5

Amazon

A teen webcomic creator navigates internet fame, first love, and a mental health crisis in this love letter to fandom and creative identity.

Amazon4.5
Common Sense Media

Where to Read

Amazon
Amazon
Barnes & Noble
Barnes & Noble
Libby
Libby

Our reviews and ratings are 100% unbiased, but as an Amazon Associate, Screenwise earns an affiliate fee if you buy a book or game by clicking one of our links. We don't get any credit if you just Google it instead :)

Screenwise Verdict

This is the book for the kid who spends hours on AO3, has strong opinions about their favorite webcomics, and feels like their online creative community gets them better than their IRL friends do.

Zappia nails the tension between digital and physical identity in a way that feels authentic to teens who've grown up online. The mental health rep is the real deal—not a quirky personality trait but a serious struggle that affects everything. The parent suicide element is heavy and might be a dealbreaker for some families, but it's handled with care.

The format is genuinely innovative and makes you feel like you're experiencing Eliza's dual life firsthand. The romance is a bonus—sweet without being the whole point. This isn't a beach read; it's an emotionally complex story that asks real questions about creativity, identity, and what happens when your two worlds collide.

If your teen is into creator culture, struggles with anxiety, or just wants to see themselves reflected in a story about making art and finding connection, this delivers. Just make sure they're ready for the emotional weight.

Age Fit

Best for mature 14+ readers who can handle heavy mental health themes including parent suicide and depression. The content isn't graphic but it's emotionally intense. Strong readers 13+ who are interested in the subject matter could handle it, but definitely not for middle schoolers looking for light contemporary romance.

WISE Breakdown
Wholesome
72

Models genuine friendship and healthy romance that develops naturally. Deals with social anxiety and depression in a realistic, empathetic way. The parent suicide backstory and Eliza's mental health crisis are heavy but handled with care. The online community aspects show both positive fandom culture and the darker sides of internet fame. Emotionally complex without being gratuitous.

Imaginative
88

The meta-narrative structure—including pages from Eliza's webcomic and forum screenshots—is genuinely creative and immersive. Celebrates fan culture, storytelling, and creative expression. The concept of a teen secretly running a massive webcomic empire is compelling and taps into modern creator culture. Inspires readers to think about their own creative outlets and online identities.

Safe
58

Contains heavy themes that could be triggering: parent suicide and its aftermath, depression, anxiety disorders, and a mental health crisis severe enough to threaten Eliza's stability. These aren't gratuitous but they're prominent. Not a book you'd hand to a sensitive 12-year-old without context. The romance is clean and the online elements are realistic without being predatory. It's emotionally safe for mature teens who can handle mental health content.

Enriching
85

Deeply validating for teens who live online or struggle with social anxiety. Offers genuine insight into fandom culture, creative identity, and the tension between online and offline life. The mental health representation is nuanced and shows both struggle and the importance of seeking help. Builds empathy for people dealing with anxiety and depression. The romance shows healthy communication. Strong 4.5/5 Amazon rating suggests it resonates meaningfully with readers.

Parent Info
✓

Why It Might Be Great

  • The format is brilliant—webcomic pages and forum screenshots make you feel like you're inside Eliza's world
  • Validates teens who feel more comfortable online than IRL without romanticizing it
  • Mental health rep is nuanced and realistic, showing both the struggle and the importance of getting help
  • The romance is genuinely sweet and models healthy communication between two anxious people
  • Speaks directly to the creator economy generation—kids who understand building something online from scratch
⚠

What to Watch For

  • Parent suicide backstory and ongoing grief—this is a significant plot element, not just mentioned in passing
  • Eliza experiences a serious mental health crisis that could be intense for sensitive readers
  • Social anxiety and depression are central themes; best for teens who can handle heavy emotional content
  • The internet fame angle might hit differently if your kid is already dealing with online pressure

Conversation Starters

  • "Do you think you'd enjoy being internet-famous, or does the idea of that many people knowing your work sound stressful?"
  • "Eliza feels like she can be herself online but not in person—have you ever felt that way?"
  • "Wallace loves Eliza's webcomic before he knows she created it. How do you think that affected their relationship?"
  • "What would you do if something you made online suddenly went viral?"
  • "The book shows both the good and bad sides of fandom. What do you think makes an online community healthy vs. toxic?"

Ask Anything

Get a personalized guide on any topic

Writing about Eliza and Her Monsters? Put this WISE score on your site