2019
WISE Score
Amazon
Forensic science meets the 1893 World's Fair in a finale that’s equal parts romantic tension and 'definitely don't look in the basement.'
4.7
4.7View →Our reviews and ratings are 100% unbiased, but as an Amazon Associate, Screenwise earns an affiliate fee if you buy a book or game by clicking one of our links. We don't get any credit if you just Google it instead :)
Capturing the Devil is a high-stakes, atmospheric end to a beloved series. It’s essentially 'CSI: Gilded Age.'
While the romance is swoon-worthy and the history is fascinating, the book leans hard into the 'Devil' part of its title. It’s graphic, occasionally grisly, and treats its serial killer subject matter with a dark seriousness.
For a teen who loves a good mystery and isn't bothered by a little blood on the Victorian lace, it’s a must-read. For anyone else, it might be a bit much.
Best for 14 and up. It's solid Young Adult fiction, but the 'Young' part is doing a lot of heavy lifting given the torture and gore. If your kid isn't into true crime or horror, they might want to skip the 'Murder Hotel' tour.
The central romance between Audrey Rose and Thomas is built on mutual respect and intellectual partnership, which is a breath of fresh air for YA. However, the 'wholesome' vibe is constantly battling the fact that they are literally dissecting bodies and hunting a sadistic serial killer.
Maniscalco does a stellar job blending the 1893 Chicago World's Fair with early forensic science. The 'Murder Hotel' setting is atmospheric and creepy, showing a high level of historical world-building and creative tension.
This is a dark book. It features graphic descriptions of murders, torture devices, and forensic autopsies. While it's 'safe' in terms of being a book, the content is intense and could be genuinely disturbing for younger or sensitive readers who aren't prepared for the gore.
It’s a fantastic entry point for historical interest in the Gilded Age and the evolution of criminology. Audrey Rose’s insistence on being a scientist in a society that wants her to be a socialite offers great themes regarding gender roles and perseverance.
If your teen has spent the last three books following Audrey Rose Wadsworth through the foggy streets of London and the castles of Romania, they know the drill: forensic science, Victorian social rebellion, and heavy romantic tension. But Capturing the Devil pivots. By moving the setting to the 1893 World’s Fair in Chicago, the series trades its Gothic atmosphere for the "White City," a place that feels modern, bright, and significantly more dangerous.
The friction here isn't just the mystery; it’s the transition from a "whodunnit" to a "how do we survive this." While the earlier books felt like a dark version of Enola Holmes, this finale leans into the territory of The Silence of the Lambs. The antagonist is based on the real-life H.H. Holmes, a figure who didn't just kill people but designed a literal "Murder Hotel" to do it. It’s worth noting that the descriptions of this architectural nightmare are intense. If your reader is used to the clinical autopsy scenes from the Stalking Jack the Ripper: Gory Autopsies and Gothic Romance guide, they’ll handle the forensic talk fine, but the psychological horror of the "hotel" traps is a step up in intensity.
The real reason this series became a juggernaut isn't just the blood; it’s the "ship" between Audrey Rose and Thomas Cresswell. Thomas is the quintessential "brilliant but arrogant" partner, and their banter is the engine that keeps a very dark book from becoming a total slog.
For parents, the takeaway is that the romance in this final installment is much more central. It’s a "will they/won't they" that finally reaches its conclusion. It’s handled with a YA lens, meaning it’s more about emotional stakes and heavy yearning than anything explicit, but the emotional maturity required to navigate their relationship is higher here than in book one. They are dealing with trauma, physical injuries, and the weight of their choices. It’s a satisfying payoff for fans, but it moves the book firmly into the older teen category.
If your teen is a fan of modern true crime or investigative thrillers like A Good Girl’s Guide to Murder, this series is the historical equivalent. It bridges the gap between "standard YA fiction" and "adult true crime."
The "how to use it well" move here is to lean into the history. The 1893 World's Fair was a massive cultural moment, debuting things like the Ferris Wheel and shredded wheat alongside the horrors of H.H. Holmes. If they finish the book and are buzzing about the setting, it’s a perfect opening to talk about how history often hides its darkest stories behind the flashiest inventions.
Just be prepared for the "Google hangover." After reading about the White City Devil, most readers immediately go down a Wikipedia rabbit hole about the real H.H. Holmes. If you aren't ready for them to see the actual, non-fiction details of the "Murder Castle," you might want to have a conversation about the line between historical fiction and the much grimmer reality.
Get a personalized guide on any topic
