Butchers of the Bayou – WISE Score & Parent Review | Screenwise

Butchers of the Bayou

Name: Screenwise
Author: Screenwise

show2023

12%

WISE Score

Two serial killers compete in depravity in this A&E true crime series that's basically trauma porn disguised as documentary.

Butchers of the Bayou

show

TV-14, 2023

12%

WISE Score

Two serial killers compete in depravity in this A&E true crime series that's basically trauma porn disguised as documentary.

Jump to

Also rated on

View →

Where to Watch

Loading streaming options...

Where-to-watch data byJustWatch

Screenwise Verdict

Look, true crime has its place, but this is the bottom of the barrel. Two serial killers competing in depravity? That's the hook? The victims were real women with families, and this series frames their murders as some kind of twisted competition.

The IMDb rating of 6.8 tells you this isn't even well-executed true crime. If you're going to watch something this disturbing, at least make it something thoughtful and respectful like 'I'll Be Gone in the Dark' or 'The Jinx.' This is A&E churning out content for the algorithm.

Absolutely zero reason for anyone under 18 to watch this, and honestly, most adults would be better off skipping it too. If you do watch, ask yourself: am I learning something meaningful, or am I just consuming trauma for entertainment?

Age Fit

This is strictly for adults 18 and older, and even then, only those with strong stomachs for graphic violence and sexual assault content. The Common Sense Media rating of 14 is wildly off-base. No teenager should be watching this.

WISE Breakdown

Wholesome

This is a true crime documentary about serial killers who raped, murdered, dismembered, and cannibalized women in Baton Rouge. The subject matter is inherently disturbing and focuses on extreme violence and sexual deviance. There's nothing emotionally healthy or age-appropriate for anyone under 18, and even for adults, this is dark, traumatic content.

Imaginative

True crime documentaries require investigative storytelling and narrative construction, but this one appears to be a straightforward recounting of horrific crimes. The 'competition' angle between two killers who never met is a unique framing device, but the genre itself is more about sensationalizing real tragedy than inspiring creativity or curiosity.

Safe

Absolutely not safe for children or teens. The content involves graphic discussions of rape, murder, dismemberment, and cannibalism. Common Sense Media rates it 14+, which seems wildly inappropriate given the subject matter. This is trigger-warning central: sexual violence, extreme gore, and deeply disturbing psychological content. Even for adults, this requires mental preparation.

Enriching

True crime can offer insights into criminal psychology, law enforcement procedures, and societal issues, but this appears to focus heavily on the 'depravity Olympics' angle between two killers. The IMDb rating of 6.8 suggests it's not particularly well-executed. There may be some educational value about forensics or criminal justice, but it's overshadowed by sensationalism.

Parent Info

✓

Why It Might Be Great

If you're deeply into true crime and can handle extremely disturbing content, it covers a lesser-known case from Baton Rouge
The 'dueling killers' angle is a unique framing for understanding how serial offenders can escalate
May provide some insight into law enforcement challenges when dealing with multiple active serial killers

⚠

What to Watch For

Graphic descriptions of rape, murder, dismemberment, and cannibalism - this is not background TV
Heavy focus on 'who can be more depraved' creates a sensationalized competition narrative around real victims
Common Sense Media's 14+ rating is absurdly low - this is 18+ content, full stop
The exploitation factor is high; question whether watching serves education or just morbid curiosity

Conversation Starters

"This isn't for kids, but if you're watching: What responsibility do documentary makers have to victims' families?"
"How does true crime coverage affect public perception of crime rates and safety?"
"When does 'raising awareness' cross into exploitation?"

Ask Anything

Get a personalized guide on any topic