Our reviews and ratings are 100% unbiased. Screenwise is a Bookshop.org affiliate and an Amazon Associate, so if you buy a book through one of our links, we may earn a commission. Bookshop.org purchases also support independent bookstores.
Screenwise Verdict
This is the rare picture book that earns its awards without feeling like homework. Santat's premise is clever—what if imaginary friends are waiting for us, not the other way around?—and the execution is lovely without tipping into treacle.
The art is genuinely stunning (hence the Caldecott), and the emotional beat of Beekle deciding to stop waiting and take action is surprisingly sophisticated for a picture book. It's a story about agency and reciprocity in friendship, wrapped in a tale about a marshmallow-looking creature on an adventure.
Some critics note the pacing sags a bit in the middle, and yeah, there are a couple extra obstacles that could've been trimmed. But this is a minor quibble in an otherwise excellent book that kids request repeatedly and parents don't mind rereading. It's sweet, it's smart, and it's the kind of story that sticks with kids as they navigate their own friendships.
Age Fit
Perfect for ages 3-8 as a read-aloud, with the sweet spot around 4-6 when kids are deep in imaginary friend territory. Adults will genuinely enjoy this one too—it's a legit Caldecott winner with gorgeous art and heart.
WISE Breakdown
Wholesome
95
A tender story about friendship and belonging that models courage, patience, and reaching out to others. The emotional arc—from waiting to taking action to finding connection—is beautifully handled without being saccharine. Common Sense Media notes it taps into the universal childhood experience of imaginary friends while celebrating the vulnerability of seeking friendship.
Imaginative
96
Caldecott Medal winner for its breathtaking art and inventive premise: imaginary friends live on an island waiting to be chosen, then one decides to reverse the journey. The concept itself is meta-imaginative—it explores the nature of imagination while inviting kids to think about where imaginary friends come from. Santat's illustrations blend dreamlike island sequences with vibrant city scenes.
Safe
98
Picture book with zero concerning content. The 'conflict' is gentle—Beekle feels overlooked and lonely, then takes a brave journey. No violence, scary imagery, or mature themes. The Horn Book notes it avoids being cloying by grounding the sweetness in real-world elements. Completely appropriate for young children.
Enriching
92
Tackles meaningful themes: the courage to take initiative when life isn't going as planned, the importance of being chosen and choosing others, and how friendship requires vulnerability from both sides. The story subtly teaches that sometimes you have to go find your people rather than wait passively. Strong 4.7 Amazon rating and Caldecott recognition signal lasting impact.
Parent Info
✓
Why It Might Be Great
Flips the script: the imaginary friend chooses the child, teaching kids that sometimes you have to make the first move in friendship
Stunning illustrations that won the Caldecott Medal—the art alone is worth the read
Validates the loneliness of waiting to be picked while celebrating the courage it takes to reach out
Works on multiple levels: young kids enjoy the journey, older kids (and parents) catch the deeper themes about initiative and belonging
Short enough for bedtime but meaty enough for real conversations about friendship
⚠
What to Watch For
Some reviews note the pacing drags slightly in the middle—Beekle's search has a few obstacles that slow things down
The third-person narration means no dialogue, which some kids might find less engaging than conversation-heavy books
Very young kids (under 3) might not grasp the meta-concept of imaginary friends being imaginary
Conversation Starters
"If you could have any imaginary friend, what would they be like? What would you name them?"
"Beekle got tired of waiting and decided to find his friend himself. Have you ever had to be brave and make the first move with someone new?"
"Why do you think the girl needed Beekle as much as he needed her?"
"What do you think happens on that island where imaginary friends are born? Who else lives there?"