Name: Screenwise
Author: Screenwise

Where to Watch

Loading streaming options...

Screenwise Verdict

Here's the thing: A Good Year isn't bad, it's just... there. Ridley Scott directing a romantic comedy sounds interesting on paper, but the execution is languid and predictable. Critics savaged it (26% on RT), and even audiences who liked it only mustered a 66%—that's 'it was fine, I guess' territory.

The movie has a decent message about slowing down and choosing life over profit, but it's buried under so much leisurely pacing and rom-com formula that it never lands with impact. Russell Crowe is charming enough, Provence looks stunning, and if you're in the mood for something utterly undemanding while folding laundry, this works.

But as a Screenwise recommendation? It's too slow for kids, too dated for teens, and too forgettable for most adults to seek out. The sexual content and pervasive drinking mean it's adults-only anyway. If you're looking for a thoughtful movie about life choices, there are better options. If you want a rom-com, there are funnier ones. This sits in the middle—pleasant, pretty, and ultimately skippable.

Age Fit

This is squarely for adults—the PG-13 rating is accurate, but realistically, no teenager is going to voluntarily sit through a slow 2006 rom-com about a banker and a vineyard. It's date-night fare for parents who want something low-stakes and pretty.

WISE Breakdown

Wholesome

72

Ridley Scott's romantic comedy centers on personal transformation and rediscovering what matters—family, love, and slowing down. Max's journey from cutthroat banker to appreciating life's simple pleasures models positive character growth. The Provence setting and uncle-nephew relationship flashbacks add warmth. However, Max starts as fairly unlikeable and self-centered, which takes time to overcome. Some mild sexual content and wine-focused lifestyle may not align with all family values.

Imaginative

58

The film offers picturesque French countryside visuals and the romantic fantasy of inheriting a vineyard, but it's a fairly conventional rom-com formula. There's little that sparks genuine curiosity or invites creative thinking—it's more escapist daydream than imaginative storytelling. The inheritance-leads-to-romance plot is predictable, and while the setting is beautiful, the narrative doesn't encourage exploration of new ideas or perspectives beyond 'maybe slow down and smell the rosé.'

Safe

68

Rated PG-13 by Common Sense Media, this is generally safe but has some content parents should know about. There's sexual content (implied sex, some sensuality), drinking throughout (it's about wine, after all), and some mild language. No graphic violence, gore, or traumatic content. The main safety consideration is the romantic/sexual elements and alcohol normalization, which are present but not excessive. Not a movie that will traumatize anyone, but definitely not for young kids.

Enriching

54

The film touches on themes of work-life balance, reconnecting with childhood joy, and choosing relationships over money—all valuable lessons. However, it's wrapped in such a predictable, lightweight package that the enrichment feels surface-level. The French setting offers some cultural exposure, and there's a message about legacy and family history. But honestly, it's mostly just pleasant entertainment without much depth. The 26% critic score on Rotten Tomatoes reflects that it's not particularly substantive or memorable.

Parent Info

✓

Why It Might Be Great

Gorgeous Provence cinematography—if nothing else, it's a 2-hour vacation for your eyeballs
Positive message about choosing life and relationships over corporate greed and money
Russell Crowe and Marion Cotillard have decent chemistry, and the romance is sweet if predictable
Could spark conversations about what 'the good life' actually means and whether success equals happiness

⚠

What to Watch For

Sexual content—implied sex scenes, some sensuality, definitely not family movie night material
Drinking throughout (it's literally about wine), which normalizes alcohol as central to the good life
Slow pacing that modern kids (and many adults) will find boring—this is 2006 leisurely storytelling
The protagonist is pretty unlikeable for the first chunk of the film

Conversation Starters

"Max gives up his high-paying job for a simpler life—do you think that's brave or foolish? What would you choose?"
"The movie shows childhood memories as really important to who Max becomes. What are some of your favorite memories that you think will stick with you?"
"If you inherited a vineyard in France, would you keep it or sell it? Why?"

Ask Anything

Get a personalized guide on any topic