Name: Screenwise
Author: Screenwise

Where to Watch

Loading streaming options...

Screenwise Verdict

Here's the thing: this is a perfectly decent inspirational sports movie with good intentions and a true story at its heart. The 98% audience score tells you it works for people who love this genre.

But let's be real—the 44 Metacritic and 62% critic score also tell you it's formulaic, probably heavy-handed, and lacking the creative spark that would make it truly memorable. It's the kind of movie that feels like homework disguised as entertainment.

For modern kids? This is a tough sell. The Depression-era setting, slow pacing, and earnest tone make it feel dated even though it came out in 2021. Most kids under 15 will find it boring. Teens who genuinely love football or historical dramas might connect with it, but it's not must-watch material.

The themes are solid—resilience, mentorship, finding dignity in hardship—but there are more engaging ways to explore these ideas. If your teen is studying the Great Depression or needs to see a wholesome sports story, sure. Otherwise, this one's skippable without missing much.

Age Fit

Best for ages 12-16 who can handle heavy themes about poverty, orphans, and historical hardship. The earnest, slow-paced storytelling and period setting will bore most modern kids under 12, and teens 17+ will likely find it too sentimental and predictable unless they're really into sports dramas.

WISE Breakdown

Wholesome

78

Classic underdog sports story that models perseverance, teamwork, and mentorship. A coach helps orphaned boys find purpose and dignity during the Great Depression. The emotional tone emphasizes resilience and community support, though the setting involves poverty and hardship that could be heavy for younger viewers.

Imaginative

42

Straightforward historical sports drama with minimal creative flair. It's a true story told conventionally—inspirational but formulaic. Doesn't invite much creative thinking or exploration beyond the standard sports movie playbook. The Depression-era setting adds historical context but the narrative structure is predictable.

Safe

72

Common Sense Media rates it 13+, suggesting some mature content. Historical context includes poverty, likely abuse references in an orphanage setting, and the coach's 'mysterious past' hints at trauma. Sports violence would be period-appropriate football. No indication of graphic content, but the emotional weight of orphans and Depression-era hardship could be difficult. Lacks detailed content warnings in available data.

Enriching

68

Strong themes of resilience, mentorship, and overcoming adversity. Offers historical perspective on the Great Depression and how sports can provide hope and structure. The true story element adds educational value. However, the 62% critic score and 44 Metacritic suggest execution may be heavy-handed or overly sentimental, limiting deeper engagement.

Parent Info

✓

Why It Might Be Great

True story showcasing resilience and the power of mentorship during America's darkest economic period
Strong themes of teamwork, dignity, and finding purpose when life deals you a terrible hand
98% audience score suggests it hits the emotional beats effectively for viewers who connect with earnest sports dramas
Historical context offers a window into 1930s America and how communities rallied around hope
Models positive male mentorship and shows how structure and belonging can transform young lives

⚠

What to Watch For

Heavy emotional content—orphans, poverty, likely references to abuse or neglect that come with institutional care in the 1930s
The coach's 'mysterious past' suggests trauma or wartime experiences that may be explored
Formulaic sports movie beats mean it's predictable; critics gave it 44 on Metacritic for a reason
Pacing is likely slow and earnest in that 2021-historical-drama way that modern kids find boring
Rated 13+ by Common Sense Media, so not for younger elementary kids

Conversation Starters

"What do you think made the biggest difference for these boys—having a coach who believed in them, or having a team to belong to?"
"The movie is set during the Great Depression when lots of families couldn't afford to keep their kids. How different was childhood back then?"
"Do you think sports can really change someone's life, or is that just movie magic?"
"The coach had his own traumatic past but still showed up for these kids. Why do you think helping others sometimes helps us heal?"

Ask Anything

Get a personalized guide on any topic

12 Mighty Orphans